Everything K-culture — comebacks to K-beauty, straight to your inboxGet it in your inbox›
Reference-Free Post-Training of Open Large Language Models for Multilingual Machine Translation
arXiv:2608.108122026-08-12
An open multilingual translation model that improves without ever seeing a correct translation, using reinforcement learning
Researchers post-trained the open MiLMMT-46 language models across 46 languages using reinforcement learning (GRPO) driven by two reference-free quality-estimation scorers and a language-identification gate, instead of relying on labeled reference translations. Blending the resulting RL checkpoint with the original supervised model at a 50/50 ratio produced MiLMMT-46-v1.0, which scored higher on reference-free metrics than open baselines like Seed-X, HY-MT2, and TranslateGemma, and matched or beat evaluated proprietary systems including Google Translate, Gemini 3 Pro, and GPT-5. A follow-up experiment distilling the 12B model into smaller 1B and 4B students came close to but did not surpass the quality achieved by RL plus checkpoint blending.
METAL MEDIA explanatory visual
MiLMMT-46 reference-free post-training pipeline
Evidence statusMeasured results reported
Start: MiLMMT-46-v0.1Supervised-finetuned open multilingual model covering 46 languages at 1B/4B/12B scale
Reward design + GRPO RLAverage XCOMET and COMETKiwi scores on source-translation pairs, gated by a language-ID check that penalizes wrong-language output, trained via GRPO to produce MiLMMT-46-v0.1-RL
Checkpoint interpolationLinearly blend SFT and RL weights at alpha=0.5 to produce the final MiLMMT-46-v1.0
Benchmark comparisonCompared reference-free scores on WMT24++ and FLORES+ against open baselines (Seed-X, HY-MT2, TranslateGemma) and proprietary systems (Google Translate, Gemini 3 Pro, GPT-5)
On-policy distillation experimentUsed the 12B model as teacher to train 1B/4B students; students approached but did not surpass the RL+interpolation quality frontier
An explanatory diagram made by METAL MEDIA, not a figure supplied by the paper's authors.
What they did
Standard translation model improvement relies on reference (correct) translations, which are scarce for low-resource languages; this work instead trains using only source sentences, without references.
Starting from the supervised-finetuned MiLMMT-46-v0.1 models, the team applied GRPO reinforcement learning with a reward averaging two reference-free quality-estimation models (XCOMET, COMETKiwi), gated by a language-identification check that penalizes outputs in the wrong language.
To counteract quality drift or reward-hacking side effects from pure RL, they linearly blended (interpolated) the SFT checkpoint and the RL checkpoint at a 50/50 ratio (alpha=0.5), producing the final MiLMMT-46-v1.0 models.
Across three model sizes (1B, 4B, 12B), the resulting models improved reference-free XCOMET and COMETKiwi scores on WMT24++ by an average of 2.75 and 2.44 points respectively over their SFT counterparts, and MiLMMT-46-v1.0 achieved leading reference-free scores against Seed-X, HY-MT2, TranslateGemma, and proprietary systems including Google Translate, Gemini 3 Pro, and GPT-5.
A separate on-policy distillation experiment transferred knowledge from the 12B teacher to 1B and 4B student models; the students approached but did not exceed the quality frontier set by RL plus checkpoint interpolation.
Figure 1: Training and validation rewards during GRPO post-training at the 1B, 4B, and 12B scales. Validation rewards are evaluated every 50 training steps.
Table 1: Translation performance on WMT24++ and FLORES+. WMT24++ QE cells report reference-free XCOMET / COMETKiwi. For FLORES+, Ref. cells report spBLEU / reference-based XCOMET, while QE cells report reference-free XCOMET / COMETKiwi. The best and second-best scores for each metric within each language-coverage block are shown in bold and underlined, respectively. Detailed reference-free and reference-based results are provided in Appendix D.1 and Appendix D.2, respectively.
Model
WMT24++
FLORES+
en → xx
en → xx
xx → en
zh → xx
xx → zh
QE
Ref.
QE
Ref.
QE
Ref.
QE
Ref.
QE
21 languages
Tower-Plus-2B
82.52/76.30
40.41/92.65
94.10/88.53
42.54/94.61
94.88/89.77
24.27/88.56
87.99/78.87
29.53/84.65
71.29/76.52
Tower-Plus-9B
86.80/80.76
43.33/95.09
95.93/91.05
45.32/96.03
95.84/90.44
27.59/92.65
90.73/80.68
33.25/88.09
73.95/78.59
Tower-Plus-72B
86.25/80.21
42.74/94.86
95.76/90.71
45.89/96.26
96.00/90.51
28.50/92.92
90.55/80.41
35.06/89.17
74.61/78.88
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
83.28/76.69
36.87/92.02
93.88/88.03
41.10/94.45
95.15/89.73
22.94/87.49
87.57/78.29
28.20/85.39
74.03/77.78
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
89.11/82.77
39.85/95.64
96.67/91.85
43.45/96.06
96.33/90.57
26.53/92.83
91.38/82.07
31.47/89.49
76.77/80.45
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
90.77/84.55
40.66/96.60
97.39/92.88
44.59/96.55
96.53/90.77
28.03/94.43
92.28/83.14
32.19/90.79
78.01/81.43
26 languages
Seed-X-Instruct-7B
85.19/78.30
44.16/94.45
95.30/90.17
44.54/93.10
91.92/88.67
28.60/90.43
85.68/80.96
32.51/87.60
68.36/79.97
Seed-X-PPO-7B
86.18/79.99
45.48/95.02
95.95/91.10
44.12/95.92
95.73/90.51
29.65/92.80
89.32/83.88
29.20/88.86
68.90/80.88
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
83.42/77.21
37.72/92.39
94.19/88.66
41.72/94.28
94.87/89.82
23.12/87.32
86.75/80.83
27.89/85.04
73.44/79.45
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
89.19/83.25
40.50/95.87
96.86/92.40
44.30/95.94
96.06/90.68
26.72/92.75
90.63/84.79
31.36/89.32
76.30/82.31
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
90.88/85.00
41.18/96.84
97.58/93.46
45.43/96.45
96.28/90.89
28.15/94.34
91.58/85.74
32.39/90.72
77.58/83.28
28 languages
GemmaX2-28-2B-v0.2
80.95/77.35
37.38/90.14
92.42/87.69
42.29/92.52
91.86/88.28
25.06/86.56
85.32/79.71
29.70/83.57
68.60/78.17
GemmaX2-28-9B-v0.2
84.19/80.28
40.04/92.66
94.32/89.56
44.53/94.02
92.88/88.81
27.67/90.27
87.94/81.75
32.39/86.42
70.41/79.78
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
79.73/75.97
33.12/88.23
91.22/86.37
38.73/91.24
91.23/87.73
21.43/83.24
83.36/78.35
26.28/81.48
68.84/77.60
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
86.13/81.81
36.16/93.19
95.05/90.30
42.05/93.86
93.09/88.75
25.01/90.03
88.47/82.29
30.11/86.55
71.54/80.32
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
88.09/83.57
36.82/94.58
96.01/91.39
43.44/94.62
93.52/89.00
26.39/91.93
89.55/83.19
31.35/88.20
72.84/81.30
31 languages
HY-MT1.5-1.8B
83.88/77.38
24.81/88.51
91.80/85.31
25.25/88.51
87.51/84.01
17.60/82.79
84.93/74.74
22.61/82.58
70.06/77.06
Hunyuan-MT-7B
84.51/80.71
27.84/89.97
92.37/88.53
30.20/89.90
88.29/85.76
20.83/85.89
84.55/78.08
22.98/85.35
71.69/79.15
HY-MT1.5-7B
84.42/80.85
28.97/90.16
92.37/88.78
31.68/90.44
88.87/86.20
20.61/86.38
85.45/79.35
23.59/86.18
72.45/79.10
HY-MT2-1.8B
82.61/78.30
30.97/88.40
91.14/86.20
32.29/88.57
88.29/85.83
21.31/85.17
84.87/76.82
24.82/82.60
70.89/75.74
HY-MT2-7B
86.21/81.86
34.84/92.10
93.92/89.68
38.79/92.57
91.36/87.78
23.24/89.29
87.69/80.14
25.35/88.08
73.79/78.36
HY-MT2-30B-A3B
86.44/82.58
34.94/92.30
93.87/90.24
40.07/93.90
91.98/88.08
24.38/89.92
87.79/78.25
29.91/88.83
73.68/78.60
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
78.95/75.94
32.54/87.82
90.76/86.40
37.95/91.06
90.80/87.37
21.89/83.36
83.74/77.14
26.64/81.85
69.44/76.82
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
85.48/81.82
35.61/92.90
94.71/90.28
41.24/93.75
92.69/88.39
25.30/89.85
88.66/80.74
30.36/86.79
72.12/79.31
Figure 2: Trade-off between spBLEU and reference-based XCOMET under SFT–RL checkpoint interpolation on FLORES+, averaged over four translation-direction groups: en → xx, xx → en, zh → xx, and xx → zh. Each colored curve corresponds to one model scale, and α denotes the SFT weight. The MiLMMT-46-v0.1-RL and MiLMMT-46-v0.1 checkpoints form the two endpoints of each curve. Circled points indicate the selected MiLMMT-46-v1.0 checkpoints at α=0.5. External systems are included for comparison.
Table 2: On-policy distillation from MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0 into 1B and 4B students, averaged over 46 languages. The v1.0 baseline is obtained through RL and checkpoint interpolation, and parenthetical labels indicate the student initialization. WMT24++ reports reference-free XCOMET, while FLORES+ reports spBLEU and reference-based XCOMET. RL + OPD adopts λ=1. Full per-group results and results for all tested values of λ are provided in Appendix E.
Model
WMT24++
FLORES+
1B
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
79.01
30.51 / 85.94
OPD (init. v0.1)
77.67
30.47 / 85.22
RL + OPD (init. v0.1)
78.25
30.49 / 85.67
OPD (init. v1.0)
77.86
30.39 / 85.42
4B
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
85.86
33.96 / 90.91
OPD (init. v0.1)
85.42
34.17 / 90.82
RL + OPD (init. v0.1)
85.85
33.98 / 90.98
OPD (init. v1.0)
85.37
34.16 / 90.79
Table 3: Number of instances for each translation direction in the RL training data, sorted by training count. All 192 directions are shown (30,572 training / 1,000 validation in total).
Direction
Train
Val
Direction
Train
Val
Direction
Train
Val
en → ru
2205
73
cs → ta
71
2
hu → es
32
1
en → cs
1776
68
pl → yue
68
4
zhs → hi
32
1
en → de
1479
47
hu → th
68
1
ur → ru
31
2
en → ja
1327
43
ta → sl
63
0
ro → pt
31
1
en → bn
1219
38
bn → ar
62
0
uz → kk
31
0
ja → en
1189
47
ru → tr
60
0
nb → fa
30
2
en → zhs
775
18
my → en
57
3
bg → sk
30
1
bn → en
726
19
hi → ta
56
1
cs → el
30
1
km → en
689
24
th → tr
55
2
it → th
30
1
ru → en
664
25
el → uz
53
4
lo → en
29
2
en → tr
644
22
fr → az
53
4
sl → da
29
2
de → en
620
17
sk → lo
53
1
da → ms
29
1
en → fr
612
15
el → km
53
0
fr → nb
29
1
en → he
598
18
fi → id
52
3
kk → nl
29
1
tr → en
510
22
az → tl
52
1
ca → bg
28
0
fr → de
463
17
hi → ms
51
0
bg → ro
27
1
en → pt
446
11
hr → tr
51
0
my → zht
27
0
de → fr
441
13
my → ur
50
3
ca → ru
25
0
en → uz
437
23
ur → bg
50
2
es → nl
25
0
cs → en
389
16
ur → hr
50
1
ms → sv
25
0
en → km
362
8
el → fi
49
4
fa → de
22
2
en → az
359
10
fi → ur
48
3
nb → bg
22
2
en → my
358
12
sk → ar
48
3
ru → es
22
1
en → it
336
12
it → tr
48
1
es → fr
22
0
en → tl
315
8
hr → zht
47
1
kk → ca
21
1
en → yue
306
11
bg → fi
47
0
pl → es
21
0
en → ur
300
13
ur → nl
46
0
es → bn
20
2
fi → en
300
12
az → km
45
3
el → ro
20
0
en → ta
294
5
tr → ca
45
2
fr → es
20
0
en → es
279
6
zht → kk
45
1
pt → ms
20
0
Table 4: 46 languages supported by our model. The resource of each language is determined according to the taxonomy classes by Joshi et al. (2020).
ISO Code
Language
Script
Family
Subgrouping
Resource
ar
Arabic
Arabic
Afro-Asiatic
Semitic
High
az
Azerbaijani
Latin
Turkic
Common Turkic
Low
bg
Bulgarian
Cyrillic
Indo-European
Balto-Slavic
Mid
bn
Bengali
Bengali
Indo-European
Indo-Aryan
Mid
ca
Catalan
Latin
Indo-European
Italic
High
cs
Czech
Latin
Indo-European
Balto-Slavic
High
da
Danish
Latin
Indo-European
Germanic
Mid
de
German
Latin
Indo-European
Germanic
High
el
Greek
Greek
Indo-European
Graeco-Phrygian
Mid
en
English
Latin
Indo-European
Germanic
High
es
Spanish
Latin
Indo-European
Italic
High
fa
Persian
Arabic
Indo-European
Iranian
High
fi
Finnish
Latin
Uralic
Finnic
High
fr
French
Latin
Indo-European
Italic
High
he
Hebrew
Hebrew
Afro-Asiatic
Semitic
Mid
hi
Hindi
Devanagari
Indo-European
Indo-Aryan
High
hr
Croatian
Latin
Indo-European
Balto-Slavic
High
hu
Hungarian
Latin
Uralic
-
High
id
Indonesian
Latin
Austronesian
Malayo-Polynesian
Mid
it
Italian
Latin
Indo-European
Italic
High
ja
Japanese
Japanese
Japonic
Japanesic
High
kk
Kazakh
Cyrillic
Turkic
Common Turkic
Mid
km
Khmer
Khmer
Austroasiatic
Khmeric
Low
ko
Korean
Hangul
Koreanic
Korean
High
lo
Lao
Lao
Tai-Kadai
Kam-Tai
Low
ms
Malay
Latin
Austronesian
Malayo-Polynesian
Mid
my
Burmese
Myanmar
Sino-Tibetan
Burmo-Qiangic
Low
nb
Norwegian
Latin
Indo-European
Germanic
Low
nl
Dutch
Latin
Indo-European
Germanic
High
pl
Polish
Latin
Indo-European
Balto-Slavic
High
Table 5: GRPO training hyper-parameters, shared across all three model scales.
Hyper-parameter
Value
Optimization
Actor learning rate
1e−6
Batch size (prompts)
128
PPO mini-batch size
128
Total epochs
3
KL loss type
low-variance KL
KL coefficient β
1e−3
Gradient checkpointing
Enabled
Rollout / sampling
Inference backend
vLLM
Group size G
8
Temperature
0.8
Top-p
0.95
Max prompt length
4096 tokens
Max response length
4096 tokens
Reward (reference-free)
Quality metrics
XCOMET, COMETKiwi
Language-matched reward
12(XCOMET+COMETKiwi)
Language-mismatch reward
0
Language identification
OpenLID-v3
Table 6: Reference-free evaluation results (XCOMET / COMETKiwi) of baseline models (Part I) on the WMT24++ benchmark.
Direction
TranslateGemma-4B
TranslateGemma-12B
TranslateGemma-27B
GemmaX2-28-2B
GemmaX2-28-9B
Hunyuan-MT-7B
HY-MT1.5-1.8B
HY-MT1.5-7B
HY-MT2-1.8B
HY-MT2-7B
HY-MT2-30B-A3B
Seed-X-Instruct-7B
Seed-X-PPO-7B
Tower-Plus-2B
Tower-Plus-9B
Tower-Plus-72B
en → ar
82.93 / 78.21
86.54 / 81.66
87.12 / 83.01
77.96 / 74.33
82.34 / 78.80
88.87 / 82.85
85.12 / 78.51
88.98 / 82.66
83.57 / 78.39
87.70 / 82.24
88.27 / 82.49
80.33 / 75.78
81.80 / 77.34
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → az
39.43 / 45.81
71.65 / 76.53
77.85 / 81.72
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → bg
83.19 / 77.11
88.78 / 83.66
89.77 / 84.98
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → bn
78.79 / 75.57
84.04 / 79.68
84.95 / 80.72
78.80 / 77.55
81.61 / 79.78
86.50 / 80.30
83.05 / 75.73
86.77 / 80.81
81.93 / 77.34
86.77 / 81.94
87.50 / 82.22
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → ca
79.59 / 71.97
85.65 / 78.91
86.59 / 80.12
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → cs
80.07 / 75.12
86.54 / 81.74
87.55 / 83.54
78.78 / 71.86
83.84 / 77.78
88.05 / 82.53
82.61 / 75.88
87.58 / 82.28
82.60 / 74.60
87.49 / 80.68
88.50 / 82.13
83.43 / 76.69
84.35 / 77.67
76.91 / 69.83
83.61 / 77.82
83.06 / 76.78
en → da
90.04 / 81.51
92.74 / 85.16
93.64 / 86.29
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
90.64 / 80.69
90.67 / 81.25
87.69 / 77.84
89.94 / 80.45
90.01 / 80.16
en → de
93.06 / 77.75
93.22 / 80.63
94.79 / 81.52
92.23 / 76.92
93.67 / 80.11
95.37 / 81.85
94.43 / 78.08
95.35 / 81.66
93.04 / 77.62
94.86 / 80.95
95.13 / 81.74
92.96 / 78.49
92.90 / 79.11
90.98 / 75.69
93.53 / 79.49
93.50 / 79.62
en → el
80.47 / 74.71
86.77 / 81.08
88.44 / 83.48
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → es
89.00 / 78.97
90.61 / 81.65
90.90 / 82.53
87.25 / 77.30
89.35 / 80.00
92.03 / 82.68
91.73 / 80.90
92.20 / 82.50
89.81 / 78.91
91.60 / 81.03
92.14 / 82.07
87.51 / 76.46
87.88 / 77.68
86.48 / 76.19
88.95 / 79.12
89.26 / 79.77
en → fa
79.77 / 77.50
85.90 / 83.49
87.56 / 84.94
78.73 / 78.25
83.25 / 82.22
86.53 / 82.36
82.33 / 77.46
86.45 / 82.69
81.30 / 78.27
86.63 / 83.59
87.53 / 84.72
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → fi
83.44 / 80.94
88.96 / 86.47
90.49 / 88.28
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
87.09 / 82.39
87.74 / 84.15
80.14 / 77.12
87.95 / 84.78
84.80 / 80.91
en → fr
84.52 / 78.40
87.37 / 81.47
87.44 / 82.54
83.77 / 76.44
86.09 / 79.03
88.73 / 82.09
87.31 / 78.83
88.97 / 82.00
86.28 / 78.09
87.67 / 79.95
89.02 / 81.71
85.68 / 77.51
85.42 / 78.28
81.46 / 74.36
86.28 / 79.80
86.85 / 79.88
en → he
76.75 / 71.40
84.05 / 79.29
86.31 / 81.14
78.41 / 73.43
82.23 / 77.52
78.48 / 70.66
76.35 / 68.93
78.34 / 71.17
76.90 / 70.31
84.75 / 78.57
85.67 / 79.95
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → hi
75.17 / 68.43
82.54 / 72.27
83.76 / 73.75
73.22 / 69.70
76.77 / 71.42
86.01 / 70.11
82.27 / 66.61
86.03 / 71.64
80.16 / 70.42
84.96 / 73.68
85.67 / 74.11
- / -
- / -
66.30 / 66.88
73.08 / 70.57
70.08 / 69.26
en → hr
80.35 / 75.45
87.39 / 82.84
89.60 / 85.46
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
82.19 / 75.46
83.71 / 77.94
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → hu
75.53 / 71.64
86.27 / 82.75
89.31 / 85.95
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
86.25 / 81.26
87.24 / 83.06
80.16 / 76.36
86.62 / 83.10
83.46 / 79.47
en → id
88.84 / 81.48
91.54 / 84.58
91.59 / 84.77
87.36 / 80.40
88.77 / 81.96
92.94 / 85.37
91.85 / 83.07
92.80 / 85.53
90.54 / 82.87
92.53 / 84.87
92.81 / 85.16
85.14 / 77.06
85.79 / 78.69
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → it
87.65 / 79.94
88.70 / 82.44
89.63 / 83.06
85.89 / 76.99
87.81 / 79.74
91.37 / 83.68
89.98 / 80.96
91.50 / 83.48
89.03 / 80.09
90.69 / 82.30
91.36 / 82.78
86.11 / 76.94
86.12 / 77.99
84.57 / 75.76
88.33 / 80.42
87.99 / 80.57
en → ja
83.02 / 84.36
87.23 / 87.40
88.47 / 88.05
84.31 / 85.03
86.62 / 86.65
90.91 / 88.98
88.71 / 86.96
90.83 / 88.90
87.95 / 86.93
90.69 / 88.78
90.92 / 88.80
83.15 / 82.85
85.19 / 84.73
83.05 / 84.49
86.60 / 86.88
87.39 / 87.18
en → kk
39.80 / 55.35
64.89 / 79.54
73.00 / 84.14
- / -
- / -
34.93 / 68.37
60.20 / 61.48
34.76 / 69.33
41.52 / 59.03
46.32 / 68.28
36.97 / 69.43
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → km
37.64 / 46.67
64.89 / 77.61
70.23 / 81.16
71.41 / 79.63
75.22 / 82.12
68.36 / 78.57
70.81 / 78.65
67.70 / 78.73
75.00 / 81.98
79.01 / 84.43
78.29 / 84.62
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → ko
85.97 / 82.51
89.88 / 85.85
90.64 / 86.69
84.02 / 82.15
88.07 / 85.49
92.21 / 87.24
89.95 / 84.97
91.77 / 87.06
88.47 / 84.94
91.96 / 87.14
91.74 / 87.23
79.96 / 77.72
83.58 / 81.42
81.83 / 80.54
86.78 / 84.44
87.09 / 84.32
en → lo
38.64 / 46.84
68.05 / 75.22
75.19 / 79.77
71.15 / 76.09
76.36 / 79.57
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → ms
83.00 / 76.45
88.75 / 82.31
89.23 / 82.52
85.13 / 78.27
86.58 / 79.42
91.58 / 83.08
90.82 / 80.83
91.44 / 83.35
89.17 / 81.03
90.72 / 82.57
91.10 / 83.08
81.27 / 73.07
82.98 / 75.48
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → my
39.71 / 56.00
55.85 / 75.06
63.73 / 79.88
66.36 / 78.74
73.53 / 82.35
62.45 / 76.34
66.14 / 77.59
62.74 / 76.23
71.04 / 81.55
75.00 / 83.04
76.80 / 84.68
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → nb
89.83 / 82.89
92.36 / 86.34
93.42 / 87.03
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
86.75 / 76.16
88.51 / 79.61
86.80 / 78.31
87.08 / 78.40
86.53 / 77.89
en → nl
90.10 / 80.01
92.89 / 84.14
93.67 / 85.03
89.74 / 79.56
92.24 / 82.94
92.60 / 82.34
90.91 / 79.30
92.25 / 82.37
89.46 / 79.20
93.26 / 83.24
94.06 / 84.81
91.43 / 80.74
91.88 / 82.37
88.66 / 78.27
91.68 / 82.18
91.86 / 82.59
en → pl
85.33 / 76.77
89.51 / 82.21
90.29 / 83.63
83.41 / 74.66
87.14 / 79.11
86.22 / 78.20
84.10 / 74.69
86.31 / 78.11
83.38 / 73.85
89.28 / 80.77
91.35 / 82.83
87.45 / 78.50
88.00 / 79.62
81.70 / 72.82
88.18 / 80.01
87.22 / 78.84
en → pt
89.87 / 81.24
91.26 / 83.63
91.57 / 84.42
88.22 / 79.29
90.19 / 81.81
92.56 / 84.15
91.50 / 81.97
92.59 / 84.48
90.67 / 81.01
91.44 / 82.21
92.20 / 83.28
87.36 / 77.40
88.11 / 79.23
86.20 / 77.25
89.02 / 80.76
89.26 / 81.47
Table 7: Reference-free evaluation results (XCOMET / COMETKiwi) of baseline models (Part II) and MiLMMT models on the WMT24++ benchmark.
Direction
Google Translate
NLLB-54.5B
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Gemini 3 Pro
GPT-5
MiLMMT-46-1B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-4B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-12B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
en → ar
86.44 / 81.97
- / -
84.85 / 81.08
85.10 / 81.20
84.36 / 81.56
74.32 / 71.17
78.72 / 75.15
82.17 / 78.59
86.67 / 81.80
83.68 / 80.37
89.44 / 84.33
en → az
75.04 / 78.02
- / -
78.83 / 81.72
80.01 / 82.17
80.36 / 82.29
66.15 / 69.98
73.65 / 75.98
77.81 / 79.42
83.99 / 83.98
80.36 / 81.29
87.76 / 86.56
en → bg
85.07 / 80.04
- / -
86.98 / 81.51
87.13 / 81.84
87.24 / 82.49
78.31 / 72.59
83.44 / 77.26
85.18 / 79.44
89.97 / 84.08
87.18 / 81.96
91.83 / 86.83
en → bn
76.65 / 76.64
- / -
81.98 / 79.63
84.39 / 81.09
82.14 / 80.01
73.35 / 72.87
80.44 / 77.38
81.13 / 79.21
87.39 / 81.83
82.97 / 80.67
89.00 / 83.30
en → ca
82.82 / 76.02
- / -
84.16 / 77.08
84.97 / 77.73
85.39 / 78.61
79.25 / 70.51
82.62 / 74.97
84.88 / 77.31
88.83 / 81.39
85.82 / 78.49
90.60 / 83.50
en → cs
83.42 / 77.94
- / -
85.82 / 80.02
85.95 / 80.36
86.08 / 81.57
74.07 / 66.96
79.72 / 73.77
82.84 / 77.04
87.89 / 82.89
85.99 / 80.36
90.08 / 85.44
en → da
90.57 / 81.72
- / -
91.88 / 83.64
92.15 / 84.16
92.06 / 84.59
86.69 / 76.36
89.50 / 79.45
90.86 / 81.85
93.55 / 85.42
92.14 / 83.36
95.05 / 87.05
en → de
94.57 / 81.13
- / -
93.93 / 80.31
93.84 / 80.70
93.87 / 81.08
89.73 / 73.16
91.87 / 75.70
93.32 / 79.43
94.81 / 81.13
94.11 / 80.88
95.83 / 82.72
en → el
83.85 / 78.92
- / -
86.04 / 81.08
85.76 / 80.96
86.33 / 81.45
75.94 / 70.33
79.82 / 74.29
84.67 / 78.69
88.74 / 82.62
85.97 / 81.03
91.04 / 85.24
en → es
89.20 / 79.21
- / -
89.32 / 79.50
89.46 / 79.65
89.86 / 80.50
85.69 / 74.59
88.29 / 78.24
89.02 / 79.17
92.18 / 82.46
89.79 / 80.35
93.52 / 84.39
en → fa
82.95 / 82.21
- / -
84.28 / 82.93
84.95 / 83.20
84.81 / 83.55
70.87 / 69.98
77.74 / 76.46
80.84 / 80.03
86.74 / 83.31
83.88 / 82.99
89.83 / 86.07
en → fi
88.18 / 85.06
- / -
90.53 / 87.55
90.76 / 87.38
90.23 / 88.09
75.47 / 72.56
79.05 / 75.77
86.58 / 83.34
90.13 / 86.72
89.23 / 85.77
92.83 / 89.55
en → fr
88.37 / 80.72
- / -
85.92 / 78.89
85.78 / 78.70
86.18 / 79.68
80.72 / 73.15
83.88 / 76.74
85.41 / 78.14
89.12 / 81.89
86.72 / 79.98
90.87 / 83.71
en → he
80.72 / 76.43
- / -
82.68 / 78.61
83.26 / 79.20
83.42 / 79.48
72.15 / 66.61
75.51 / 70.09
81.07 / 76.50
86.10 / 80.69
83.11 / 78.75
88.98 / 83.05
en → hi
84.30 / 74.35
- / -
79.63 / 72.28
81.11 / 73.33
81.02 / 72.74
68.30 / 66.08
75.43 / 67.59
76.95 / 71.28
84.66 / 72.50
78.71 / 72.65
87.43 / 74.67
en → hr
85.80 / 82.13
- / -
87.48 / 82.91
87.74 / 83.33
87.97 / 83.58
78.57 / 73.02
83.74 / 77.81
86.04 / 81.20
90.68 / 85.53
87.88 / 82.84
92.33 / 87.30
en → hu
86.37 / 83.60
- / -
88.66 / 85.48
88.95 / 85.20
89.45 / 86.08
75.42 / 71.75
79.77 / 75.75
85.50 / 82.16
90.04 / 85.74
88.13 / 84.92
92.35 / 88.20
en → id
90.46 / 84.30
- / -
89.55 / 83.29
89.59 / 83.12
89.86 / 83.29
84.81 / 77.44
89.02 / 81.12
88.70 / 81.60
92.67 / 85.58
89.75 / 82.48
94.04 / 86.73
en → it
87.68 / 80.30
- / -
86.98 / 79.38
87.53 / 79.56
87.94 / 80.65
83.21 / 73.62
86.62 / 78.19
88.13 / 79.58
91.32 / 83.55
88.69 / 80.86
92.37 / 85.20
en → ja
87.60 / 87.49
- / -
87.16 / 86.92
87.42 / 87.37
88.01 / 87.90
79.56 / 81.91
84.57 / 84.91
86.25 / 86.28
90.24 / 88.89
88.38 / 87.63
90.80 / 89.57
en → kk
73.37 / 83.05
- / -
75.89 / 85.17
76.34 / 84.05
76.43 / 84.91
63.49 / 75.97
67.87 / 79.67
74.60 / 83.53
78.17 / 86.36
77.03 / 85.22
81.48 / 88.07
en → km
72.83 / 81.55
- / -
74.46 / 83.33
76.32 / 83.88
74.17 / 82.78
67.64 / 76.34
71.55 / 79.96
74.93 / 82.01
79.53 / 84.45
76.71 / 83.30
81.65 / 85.75
en → ko
90.76 / 86.91
- / -
88.69 / 85.01
89.34 / 85.89
88.85 / 86.06
80.71 / 79.32
85.25 / 82.66
87.27 / 84.30
90.46 / 86.54
89.07 / 86.01
92.43 / 88.02
en → lo
73.29 / 77.81
- / -
75.11 / 80.35
76.44 / 80.81
72.83 / 78.57
66.58 / 72.10
71.54 / 76.03
76.27 / 79.50
81.09 / 81.50
77.56 / 80.36
83.41 / 83.01
en → ms
82.57 / 76.26
- / -
86.49 / 80.14
86.24 / 79.79
86.75 / 80.42
83.15 / 75.98
87.19 / 79.63
86.21 / 79.31
91.89 / 84.13
87.10 / 80.22
93.51 / 85.64
en → my
70.34 / 80.67
- / -
72.74 / 83.01
73.61 / 83.07
72.24 / 82.92
59.62 / 73.65
66.31 / 77.34
72.25 / 82.11
78.40 / 84.23
75.30 / 83.95
80.98 / 85.58
en → nb
90.21 / 83.50
- / -
91.96 / 85.05
92.31 / 85.72
92.37 / 85.87
86.78 / 78.64
89.39 / 80.85
91.30 / 83.89
93.59 / 86.49
92.33 / 84.93
94.86 / 88.18
en → nl
93.72 / 85.21
- / -
92.18 / 83.21
92.14 / 83.43
92.42 / 84.25
87.32 / 76.36
89.77 / 79.31
91.46 / 81.90
93.62 / 83.98
92.75 / 83.27
94.82 / 85.92
en → pl
87.66 / 80.20
- / -
87.76 / 80.06
87.80 / 80.38
88.21 / 81.36
77.23 / 68.06
82.43 / 73.66
85.91 / 77.83
90.37 / 82.49
88.33 / 80.65
92.55 / 84.80
en → pt
91.25 / 82.85
- / -
89.28 / 80.68
89.21 / 80.75
89.84 / 81.82
86.88 / 77.10
89.58 / 80.34
89.53 / 81.25
92.72 / 84.68
90.89 / 82.48
93.76 / 86.38
Table 8: Reference-free English-centric evaluation results (XCOMET / COMETKiwi) of baseline models (Part I) on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
TranslateGemma-4B
TranslateGemma-12B
TranslateGemma-27B
GemmaX2-28-2B
GemmaX2-28-9B
Hunyuan-MT-7B
HY-MT1.5-1.8B
HY-MT1.5-7B
HY-MT2-1.8B
HY-MT2-7B
HY-MT2-30B-A3B
Seed-X-Instruct-7B
Seed-X-PPO-7B
Tower-Plus-2B
Tower-Plus-9B
Tower-Plus-72B
en → ar
93.54 / 87.09
95.66 / 89.84
96.38 / 90.84
91.90 / 85.63
94.20 / 87.97
96.24 / 90.07
93.88 / 86.84
96.05 / 90.22
93.32 / 86.88
95.60 / 89.57
95.70 / 89.69
93.34 / 87.04
93.78 / 87.76
- / -
- / -
- / -
ar → en
87.46 / 84.55
90.50 / 85.89
91.93 / 86.59
91.31 / 86.44
92.65 / 87.19
90.88 / 85.58
88.41 / 83.29
91.20 / 85.75
89.88 / 85.05
92.30 / 86.81
92.62 / 86.69
90.08 / 85.88
92.70 / 86.99
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → az
50.49 / 54.71
87.63 / 87.30
92.72 / 91.02
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
az → en
67.08 / 83.64
76.62 / 86.34
81.93 / 87.87
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → bg
94.35 / 89.46
97.23 / 93.44
97.88 / 94.36
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bg → en
91.52 / 89.06
93.40 / 90.01
94.93 / 90.79
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → bn
90.38 / 81.97
93.58 / 85.14
94.19 / 85.99
91.40 / 84.35
93.15 / 86.05
94.81 / 86.03
92.21 / 81.61
95.05 / 86.60
91.99 / 82.94
94.80 / 86.89
95.37 / 87.59
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bn → en
83.27 / 82.49
87.26 / 84.17
89.70 / 85.15
88.99 / 85.76
90.71 / 86.67
83.57 / 81.19
85.63 / 80.88
85.57 / 82.73
85.82 / 83.39
88.70 / 85.33
90.36 / 86.00
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → ca
93.41 / 86.49
96.70 / 91.16
96.85 / 91.74
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
ca → en
91.23 / 90.53
93.42 / 91.84
94.83 / 92.26
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → cs
92.31 / 88.02
95.96 / 92.97
96.63 / 94.28
94.08 / 88.52
95.67 / 91.28
96.30 / 92.40
92.77 / 87.03
96.11 / 92.23
92.99 / 86.87
96.25 / 91.89
96.66 / 92.79
95.12 / 91.05
96.01 / 91.83
93.43 / 87.92
95.68 / 91.76
95.10 / 90.73
cs → en
92.65 / 90.36
93.93 / 91.39
95.19 / 91.99
95.39 / 91.77
96.12 / 92.16
94.12 / 90.84
92.91 / 88.80
93.99 / 90.86
94.15 / 90.32
95.79 / 92.02
95.67 / 91.85
91.50 / 90.54
95.85 / 92.22
94.65 / 91.33
95.51 / 92.23
95.83 / 92.13
en → da
96.86 / 91.47
98.21 / 93.86
98.62 / 94.75
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
97.71 / 92.56
97.75 / 92.86
96.87 / 90.90
97.76 / 92.06
97.18 / 91.61
da → en
94.88 / 92.30
95.57 / 92.79
96.61 / 93.29
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
95.43 / 92.58
97.33 / 93.74
96.52 / 93.28
97.06 / 93.60
97.25 / 93.71
en → de
98.00 / 85.26
98.66 / 87.16
98.94 / 88.25
97.88 / 85.32
98.37 / 86.99
98.73 / 87.42
97.98 / 84.32
98.69 / 87.49
97.80 / 84.32
98.55 / 86.96
98.76 / 87.99
98.45 / 86.75
98.28 / 87.17
97.75 / 84.73
98.51 / 87.15
98.58 / 87.22
de → en
95.43 / 89.92
95.98 / 90.71
96.62 / 91.25
96.86 / 91.50
97.06 / 91.63
96.18 / 90.43
95.80 / 88.68
95.96 / 90.35
95.79 / 90.41
96.88 / 91.45
96.77 / 91.30
95.64 / 90.64
97.01 / 91.68
96.28 / 91.04
96.78 / 91.42
96.93 / 91.56
en → el
92.77 / 86.77
96.12 / 90.66
96.90 / 92.41
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
el → en
89.96 / 88.16
92.20 / 89.38
93.60 / 90.10
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → es
97.52 / 91.08
97.79 / 92.01
98.11 / 92.32
97.05 / 89.59
97.57 / 90.63
98.07 / 91.88
97.76 / 90.38
97.98 / 91.90
97.29 / 89.69
97.65 / 91.16
98.01 / 91.77
97.15 / 89.41
97.32 / 89.73
96.89 / 89.03
97.83 / 91.07
97.73 / 91.07
es → en
94.11 / 90.21
95.51 / 90.83
96.22 / 91.32
96.03 / 91.20
96.41 / 91.42
95.42 / 90.22
94.92 / 88.25
95.53 / 90.40
95.43 / 90.46
96.06 / 91.14
96.33 / 91.28
91.35 / 88.18
96.61 / 91.48
95.89 / 90.85
96.08 / 91.36
96.17 / 91.39
en → fa
91.29 / 87.76
95.76 / 91.96
96.65 / 92.71
92.03 / 88.45
94.86 / 91.37
94.11 / 89.93
91.53 / 86.43
94.40 / 90.03
91.44 / 86.99
95.36 / 91.49
95.85 / 92.22
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
fa → en
87.32 / 84.38
90.78 / 85.68
93.11 / 87.02
92.94 / 87.32
93.73 / 87.82
90.49 / 85.05
87.55 / 82.54
90.97 / 85.42
88.93 / 84.65
92.47 / 87.07
93.13 / 87.37
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → fi
92.11 / 90.21
95.94 / 94.89
97.17 / 96.23
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
95.31 / 93.49
96.20 / 94.52
92.76 / 90.22
96.39 / 94.64
94.84 / 92.68
fi → en
89.48 / 89.20
92.60 / 90.42
94.23 / 90.84
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
92.15 / 90.00
94.72 / 90.81
92.35 / 89.89
94.43 / 90.99
94.60 / 90.97
en → fr
95.72 / 91.57
96.89 / 92.93
96.97 / 93.05
95.70 / 90.38
96.94 / 91.81
96.80 / 92.47
95.45 / 89.92
96.97 / 92.68
95.33 / 89.48
96.98 / 91.92
97.10 / 92.25
96.62 / 91.11
96.77 / 91.17
95.25 / 89.22
96.76 / 91.71
97.02 / 92.02
fr → en
93.51 / 91.37
94.46 / 92.00
95.20 / 92.39
96.10 / 92.46
96.20 / 92.73
95.03 / 91.50
94.08 / 89.63
94.91 / 91.56
95.35 / 91.56
96.05 / 92.45
95.85 / 92.25
92.46 / 90.56
96.21 / 92.70
95.78 / 92.29
95.90 / 92.54
95.89 / 92.64
en → he
87.79 / 79.92
94.14 / 87.65
95.68 / 89.66
91.47 / 84.40
94.21 / 87.82
90.18 / 81.22
86.99 / 77.13
90.45 / 81.86
88.62 / 79.61
94.10 / 87.21
95.13 / 88.30
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
he → en
89.92 / 85.71
93.24 / 87.51
94.62 / 88.50
94.37 / 88.29
95.24 / 89.01
91.09 / 85.77
89.52 / 83.63
91.59 / 86.24
89.79 / 85.52
94.61 / 88.29
94.90 / 88.62
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → hi
89.14 / 75.25
92.66 / 78.04
93.71 / 79.11
86.70 / 76.38
89.61 / 78.38
94.14 / 76.46
91.81 / 72.28
94.27 / 77.82
89.95 / 75.15
93.96 / 79.22
94.32 / 79.70
- / -
- / -
83.44 / 74.54
86.97 / 77.13
86.65 / 76.52
hi → en
90.52 / 77.12
93.06 / 78.38
94.17 / 80.09
93.71 / 81.86
94.89 / 82.57
92.25 / 77.84
91.51 / 76.44
93.05 / 78.55
91.70 / 79.79
94.13 / 81.61
95.02 / 81.51
- / -
- / -
92.56 / 80.92
94.73 / 82.03
94.60 / 81.87
Table 9: Reference-free English-centric evaluation results (XCOMET / COMETKiwi) of baseline models (Part II) and MiLMMT models on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
Google Translate
NLLB-54.5B
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Gemini 3 Pro
GPT-5
MiLMMT-46-1B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-4B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-12B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
en → ar
95.05 / 89.48
91.61 / 84.52
95.64 / 89.85
95.68 / 90.03
94.83 / 89.87
89.03 / 82.35
91.63 / 85.10
93.67 / 87.88
95.49 / 89.82
94.77 / 88.90
96.96 / 91.53
ar → en
92.15 / 87.00
90.63 / 85.83
92.75 / 87.02
92.56 / 87.07
92.00 / 86.93
90.24 / 85.76
91.34 / 86.04
92.39 / 86.93
92.66 / 87.06
93.11 / 87.28
93.35 / 87.37
en → az
88.43 / 86.98
85.93 / 82.51
93.82 / 92.04
94.15 / 92.24
94.28 / 92.14
84.73 / 83.88
88.48 / 87.01
92.15 / 90.09
94.86 / 92.54
93.63 / 91.42
96.67 / 93.96
az → en
85.50 / 88.87
81.21 / 87.65
86.56 / 88.83
86.65 / 88.77
86.08 / 88.74
80.83 / 86.51
83.97 / 86.94
86.01 / 88.53
87.50 / 88.38
86.60 / 88.84
88.19 / 88.80
en → bg
95.99 / 91.09
93.16 / 86.35
96.79 / 93.02
97.26 / 93.28
96.10 / 93.18
92.30 / 86.17
94.08 / 88.79
96.02 / 91.61
97.41 / 94.00
96.73 / 92.41
98.28 / 95.08
bg → en
95.26 / 91.09
92.30 / 89.50
95.36 / 91.09
95.47 / 91.16
94.87 / 91.10
94.17 / 90.26
94.80 / 90.39
95.64 / 91.17
96.00 / 91.33
95.70 / 91.37
95.89 / 91.39
en → bn
90.40 / 84.17
87.81 / 80.98
92.82 / 85.51
94.31 / 86.87
91.56 / 85.61
86.95 / 81.05
91.83 / 83.94
92.52 / 85.61
95.51 / 87.45
93.64 / 86.36
96.69 / 88.49
bn → en
90.65 / 86.72
87.64 / 85.56
90.92 / 86.64
91.11 / 86.85
90.77 / 86.65
86.46 / 84.91
88.56 / 85.21
89.81 / 86.39
91.06 / 86.30
90.99 / 86.81
91.94 / 86.78
en → ca
95.14 / 88.88
93.18 / 84.47
95.67 / 89.74
95.47 / 89.40
95.31 / 90.48
94.28 / 86.68
95.81 / 89.22
95.70 / 89.39
97.34 / 92.20
96.18 / 90.03
97.96 / 93.42
ca → en
95.20 / 92.37
92.78 / 90.99
95.10 / 92.60
95.12 / 92.59
94.63 / 92.60
94.75 / 91.99
94.57 / 91.94
95.18 / 92.65
95.42 / 92.74
95.66 / 92.94
95.74 / 92.91
en → cs
95.45 / 90.95
91.45 / 86.98
96.22 / 92.36
96.54 / 92.77
96.48 / 93.05
90.61 / 83.96
93.09 / 88.28
95.59 / 91.06
96.78 / 93.37
96.32 / 92.32
97.50 / 95.13
cs → en
95.59 / 92.14
93.20 / 90.60
95.74 / 91.89
95.74 / 91.94
95.17 / 92.16
94.28 / 90.88
95.05 / 91.19
95.76 / 91.98
96.20 / 92.24
96.04 / 92.32
96.41 / 92.49
en → da
97.66 / 92.49
96.26 / 89.10
98.34 / 93.57
98.37 / 93.80
98.10 / 94.01
96.12 / 89.10
97.01 / 90.72
97.77 / 92.65
98.58 / 94.40
98.22 / 93.60
98.96 / 95.25
da → en
97.01 / 93.73
94.70 / 91.94
97.03 / 93.56
97.23 / 93.65
96.67 / 93.52
96.48 / 93.08
96.75 / 93.30
97.36 / 93.79
97.63 / 93.82
97.36 / 93.81
97.56 / 93.89
en → de
98.77 / 87.88
97.64 / 83.49
98.49 / 87.48
98.66 / 87.91
98.01 / 87.27
96.93 / 81.77
97.57 / 83.60
98.41 / 86.63
98.75 / 87.57
98.58 / 87.35
99.10 / 88.99
de → en
96.79 / 91.41
95.46 / 90.17
96.68 / 91.25
96.79 / 91.27
96.38 / 91.28
96.04 / 90.58
96.29 / 90.69
96.71 / 91.36
97.17 / 91.69
96.96 / 91.55
97.34 / 91.76
en → el
95.24 / 89.95
93.03 / 84.24
96.28 / 91.31
96.19 / 91.44
95.57 / 91.44
90.34 / 84.29
92.22 / 86.04
95.14 / 90.09
96.72 / 91.98
95.85 / 91.24
97.59 / 93.15
el → en
94.42 / 90.65
93.10 / 89.57
94.26 / 90.54
94.41 / 90.54
93.89 / 90.53
92.61 / 89.44
93.69 / 89.70
94.60 / 90.62
95.08 / 90.68
94.77 / 90.81
95.10 / 90.95
en → es
97.30 / 90.46
95.88 / 86.63
97.50 / 90.48
97.34 / 90.38
97.27 / 91.13
96.42 / 88.53
97.43 / 90.27
97.46 / 90.42
98.42 / 92.56
97.81 / 91.13
98.81 / 93.48
es → en
95.88 / 91.16
92.47 / 87.66
95.91 / 91.17
96.10 / 91.10
95.67 / 91.20
95.67 / 90.75
96.10 / 91.04
96.38 / 91.36
96.59 / 91.45
96.56 / 91.50
96.84 / 91.72
en → fa
95.04 / 91.46
90.52 / 86.06
95.69 / 92.10
95.58 / 92.10
94.41 / 92.10
85.79 / 82.45
89.65 / 85.86
93.67 / 89.97
95.35 / 91.47
94.92 / 91.51
96.92 / 93.32
fa → en
93.83 / 87.95
90.75 / 86.40
94.07 / 87.76
93.84 / 87.73
94.18 / 87.79
90.17 / 85.89
91.84 / 86.51
93.27 / 87.46
93.91 / 87.66
94.09 / 87.99
94.57 / 88.11
en → fi
96.28 / 94.71
92.46 / 90.76
97.35 / 96.02
97.46 / 96.28
96.89 / 96.40
87.34 / 84.07
89.71 / 86.44
95.38 / 93.47
96.83 / 95.40
96.62 / 95.04
97.96 / 96.74
fi → en
94.67 / 91.00
91.37 / 89.66
94.88 / 90.81
94.82 / 90.85
94.25 / 90.76
92.16 / 89.47
93.13 / 89.59
94.96 / 90.92
95.27 / 91.02
95.54 / 91.18
95.86 / 91.16
en → fr
96.50 / 91.46
93.79 / 86.71
96.43 / 91.42
96.63 / 91.64
96.34 / 91.79
94.53 / 88.13
95.19 / 89.85
96.49 / 91.13
97.33 / 93.22
97.03 / 92.00
98.06 / 94.11
fr → en
95.46 / 92.25
94.34 / 91.25
95.46 / 92.23
95.73 / 92.05
95.31 / 92.32
95.80 / 92.24
96.16 / 92.52
96.43 / 92.74
96.59 / 92.90
96.31 / 92.72
96.60 / 92.93
en → he
93.68 / 86.87
91.81 / 83.62
94.60 / 88.54
94.90 / 88.83
93.51 / 89.08
86.04 / 77.77
87.35 / 78.58
93.32 / 86.35
95.09 / 88.32
94.69 / 88.43
96.70 / 90.58
he → en
95.08 / 88.98
91.81 / 86.96
95.22 / 88.83
95.35 / 88.89
94.21 / 88.77
91.86 / 87.09
92.52 / 87.28
95.17 / 88.76
95.09 / 88.86
95.58 / 89.11
95.53 / 89.22
en → hi
92.01 / 79.33
83.66 / 75.63
91.30 / 78.96
92.64 / 79.50
91.93 / 78.18
82.47 / 73.39
88.77 / 75.10
89.00 / 77.77
93.61 / 78.40
91.04 / 79.36
95.25 / 80.00
hi → en
94.53 / 81.74
94.04 / 81.55
95.14 / 82.28
95.14 / 82.72
94.88 / 82.06
92.11 / 81.16
92.60 / 81.31
94.61 / 82.38
95.16 / 82.28
95.01 / 82.61
95.41 / 82.24
Table 10: Reference-free Chinese-centric evaluation results (XCOMET / COMETKiwi) of baseline models (Part I) on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
TranslateGemma-4B
TranslateGemma-12B
TranslateGemma-27B
GemmaX2-28-2B
GemmaX2-28-9B
Hunyuan-MT-7B
HY-MT1.5-1.8B
HY-MT1.5-7B
HY-MT2-1.8B
HY-MT2-7B
HY-MT2-30B-A3B
Seed-X-Instruct-7B
Seed-X-PPO-7B
Tower-Plus-2B
Tower-Plus-9B
Tower-Plus-72B
zhs → ar
78.48 / 73.15
81.62 / 76.79
83.13 / 77.26
77.98 / 71.25
82.40 / 74.60
83.67 / 76.35
80.80 / 73.82
84.28 / 77.25
81.46 / 73.69
83.97 / 76.58
83.39 / 75.80
78.17 / 71.29
82.11 / 75.08
- / -
- / -
- / -
ar → zhs
68.08 / 68.66
70.55 / 70.69
71.60 / 71.19
68.83 / 70.57
71.75 / 72.40
73.04 / 71.40
70.80 / 69.76
73.87 / 71.00
72.49 / 70.83
74.49 / 71.46
74.36 / 72.82
65.91 / 70.45
65.42 / 69.60
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → az
40.12 / 51.10
75.66 / 81.55
81.98 / 84.82
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
az → zhs
42.27 / 73.69
49.12 / 78.89
50.71 / 79.92
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → bg
88.55 / 81.80
92.12 / 85.72
92.94 / 86.44
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bg → zhs
66.45 / 73.69
68.36 / 76.21
69.48 / 76.60
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → bn
84.89 / 72.44
87.52 / 76.05
89.18 / 76.30
84.72 / 73.63
88.10 / 75.71
87.97 / 74.38
84.46 / 71.06
89.20 / 77.23
85.64 / 72.10
90.41 / 75.98
90.58 / 76.10
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bn → zhs
58.79 / 70.51
62.46 / 73.46
63.78 / 74.14
61.59 / 74.57
64.42 / 76.75
61.73 / 70.15
63.92 / 70.39
64.77 / 70.57
64.98 / 71.01
67.08 / 72.70
68.69 / 76.20
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → ca
82.24 / 76.08
86.99 / 80.71
88.26 / 81.97
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
ca → zhs
63.09 / 75.26
68.51 / 79.12
67.36 / 79.76
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → cs
75.97 / 83.84
80.60 / 88.03
83.05 / 88.77
80.85 / 84.58
85.01 / 87.48
84.27 / 88.01
78.02 / 82.47
84.40 / 88.18
81.81 / 83.99
84.78 / 87.61
84.51 / 87.83
76.31 / 84.12
83.44 / 87.93
79.58 / 83.64
83.94 / 87.73
84.49 / 87.40
cs → zhs
53.03 / 80.59
57.01 / 83.56
56.60 / 83.75
54.51 / 81.37
57.24 / 82.88
60.67 / 84.48
58.41 / 81.90
61.01 / 83.50
58.88 / 81.51
61.98 / 84.18
59.96 / 84.62
48.66 / 81.84
49.70 / 82.70
51.80 / 79.16
55.00 / 82.37
55.30 / 82.89
zhs → da
90.51 / 83.73
93.00 / 86.57
93.80 / 87.71
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
90.59 / 83.59
93.23 / 86.57
91.29 / 83.50
93.36 / 85.69
93.15 / 85.29
da → zhs
75.25 / 81.93
78.48 / 84.18
78.97 / 84.75
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
72.49 / 82.93
73.27 / 83.63
74.91 / 80.68
77.84 / 83.09
77.73 / 83.94
zhs → de
93.58 / 78.67
95.69 / 81.38
96.15 / 82.46
94.44 / 79.86
95.70 / 82.26
96.15 / 81.75
93.99 / 76.73
96.17 / 81.76
94.87 / 79.66
96.30 / 82.12
96.30 / 82.95
94.33 / 80.99
95.99 / 82.56
93.85 / 78.31
95.80 / 82.39
95.91 / 82.30
de → zhs
78.15 / 82.57
82.16 / 85.62
81.83 / 86.05
81.13 / 82.21
82.44 / 83.17
83.74 / 87.67
81.20 / 85.52
83.07 / 87.28
82.34 / 84.14
83.48 / 86.34
83.39 / 86.45
77.35 / 82.49
76.07 / 84.21
78.45 / 80.33
81.78 / 83.29
81.66 / 83.53
zhs → el
80.70 / 71.70
86.61 / 76.82
87.38 / 77.67
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
el → zhs
57.34 / 62.73
60.61 / 65.49
61.18 / 65.91
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → en
96.37 / 86.48
97.02 / 87.03
97.34 / 87.76
97.01 / 87.46
97.18 / 87.85
97.26 / 87.51
96.43 / 85.71
97.15 / 87.42
96.73 / 87.09
97.46 / 87.64
97.62 / 87.92
96.63 / 87.03
97.07 / 87.65
96.54 / 87.16
97.08 / 87.69
97.28 / 87.79
en → zhs
91.98 / 87.14
94.05 / 88.92
94.45 / 89.86
92.50 / 87.66
93.21 / 88.48
95.56 / 89.93
93.68 / 88.42
95.04 / 89.84
93.08 / 88.03
95.06 / 89.91
95.11 / 90.01
93.41 / 88.63
94.31 / 89.93
90.60 / 85.96
92.33 / 88.05
93.36 / 88.95
zhs → es
89.13 / 79.18
90.31 / 80.42
90.89 / 80.66
90.48 / 79.64
91.57 / 80.95
91.55 / 79.99
90.74 / 78.09
91.82 / 80.06
91.14 / 78.80
92.80 / 80.55
92.28 / 80.88
89.53 / 80.04
91.84 / 81.10
89.53 / 78.45
91.42 / 80.80
91.70 / 81.48
es → zhs
82.86 / 79.89
85.39 / 82.74
85.74 / 83.47
83.12 / 78.17
84.94 / 80.11
87.32 / 84.86
85.88 / 82.11
87.53 / 85.02
85.75 / 80.53
87.58 / 83.75
87.28 / 83.13
79.39 / 77.85
80.55 / 81.20
80.84 / 76.66
83.31 / 78.69
84.50 / 79.71
zhs → fa
83.93 / 78.59
88.99 / 82.95
89.47 / 83.78
85.47 / 79.52
88.28 / 81.88
86.32 / 80.00
82.69 / 77.31
88.00 / 82.03
84.82 / 78.52
89.49 / 82.72
89.37 / 82.61
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
fa → zhs
73.15 / 73.14
77.01 / 75.97
78.52 / 77.11
75.31 / 74.34
77.38 / 76.38
78.11 / 76.38
75.41 / 73.26
79.96 / 76.59
76.82 / 73.74
81.05 / 77.23
80.69 / 77.84
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → fi
78.25 / 84.10
86.43 / 89.55
87.94 / 91.28
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
81.13 / 85.82
86.27 / 88.95
81.84 / 84.66
87.10 / 89.19
85.37 / 87.68
fi → zhs
51.78 / 81.33
58.78 / 83.94
58.76 / 84.36
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
48.74 / 83.40
50.42 / 83.44
53.33 / 80.88
54.77 / 82.73
57.60 / 84.19
zhs → fr
77.61 / 78.80
79.38 / 81.08
80.52 / 81.24
81.78 / 80.76
83.88 / 82.45
81.91 / 81.35
80.34 / 78.52
82.34 / 81.06
82.18 / 80.26
83.52 / 82.60
83.58 / 82.37
79.28 / 81.08
82.39 / 81.99
79.16 / 79.26
82.68 / 81.99
83.27 / 82.58
fr → zhs
66.95 / 77.46
69.83 / 80.86
70.73 / 82.41
65.94 / 74.34
67.58 / 76.05
74.52 / 83.88
71.65 / 80.80
75.00 / 84.23
69.36 / 77.94
73.90 / 82.16
72.38 / 80.62
61.52 / 75.43
63.74 / 79.59
62.97 / 72.48
66.90 / 76.02
67.00 / 76.75
zhs → he
74.10 / 69.04
83.12 / 77.32
84.16 / 78.19
79.53 / 73.07
83.94 / 77.15
76.67 / 71.23
80.78 / 63.21
78.94 / 73.19
78.62 / 70.90
85.83 / 77.89
84.86 / 77.41
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
he → zhs
70.93 / 71.50
75.31 / 74.22
76.38 / 75.01
74.17 / 73.60
75.71 / 74.82
75.40 / 74.20
74.15 / 71.48
76.22 / 73.25
75.86 / 72.04
79.27 / 74.88
79.87 / 76.09
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
Table 11: Reference-free Chinese-centric evaluation results (XCOMET / COMETKiwi) of baseline models (Part II) and MiLMMT models on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
Google Translate
NLLB-54.5B
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Gemini 3 Pro
GPT-5
MiLMMT-46-1B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-4B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-12B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
zhs → ar
79.53 / 73.09
79.30 / 71.84
82.51 / 74.67
83.14 / 74.76
83.06 / 75.46
74.88 / 68.37
77.85 / 71.85
81.05 / 73.92
83.96 / 76.94
83.03 / 75.40
84.86 / 78.05
ar → zhs
66.40 / 70.69
52.06 / 58.70
70.50 / 72.42
71.81 / 72.89
71.76 / 73.05
67.78 / 68.55
71.52 / 70.30
70.30 / 71.67
73.99 / 72.37
71.87 / 73.29
75.00 / 73.59
zhs → az
76.37 / 79.72
74.45 / 76.04
84.65 / 85.37
84.75 / 85.69
85.47 / 86.09
72.42 / 77.31
76.26 / 80.69
82.79 / 84.23
84.44 / 86.17
84.49 / 85.74
86.96 / 87.57
az → zhs
42.77 / 79.66
35.20 / 69.50
51.11 / 81.48
51.15 / 82.01
53.65 / 82.06
44.88 / 75.64
50.64 / 77.61
49.20 / 80.64
54.71 / 80.90
50.47 / 81.51
57.09 / 81.96
zhs → bg
90.64 / 82.96
87.00 / 78.52
92.39 / 85.37
92.66 / 85.35
93.18 / 86.06
86.60 / 78.50
88.93 / 81.56
92.11 / 84.75
93.20 / 86.45
92.86 / 85.62
93.85 / 87.51
bg → zhs
63.15 / 73.91
41.99 / 52.23
67.76 / 76.00
67.38 / 75.83
68.75 / 76.29
64.10 / 72.59
69.84 / 74.82
67.40 / 75.25
72.61 / 77.68
68.25 / 76.39
73.58 / 78.85
zhs → bn
83.30 / 70.64
80.46 / 67.99
87.97 / 75.47
88.97 / 76.23
89.13 / 76.45
79.75 / 69.11
85.07 / 74.04
87.50 / 75.32
90.12 / 78.07
88.52 / 76.34
91.34 / 78.99
bn → zhs
59.53 / 74.29
44.52 / 62.58
63.45 / 76.97
64.11 / 77.01
66.13 / 76.99
57.77 / 71.90
63.58 / 73.08
63.27 / 75.41
66.63 / 75.81
64.41 / 77.06
68.68 / 76.81
zhs → ca
84.07 / 78.03
80.90 / 74.83
86.85 / 80.32
87.58 / 80.52
88.66 / 81.41
83.82 / 76.11
86.97 / 79.47
88.01 / 80.52
89.23 / 82.30
88.46 / 81.14
90.52 / 83.46
ca → zhs
63.44 / 76.00
48.24 / 58.39
68.24 / 79.11
68.36 / 77.90
70.48 / 78.63
64.11 / 73.42
68.62 / 77.47
67.46 / 76.68
72.75 / 81.12
68.94 / 78.57
73.97 / 82.41
zhs → cs
81.01 / 85.66
75.05 / 80.70
84.32 / 87.73
85.25 / 88.25
85.86 / 88.66
75.07 / 79.51
78.98 / 83.85
84.87 / 87.06
84.94 / 88.82
85.68 / 88.18
85.49 / 89.68
cs → zhs
51.19 / 81.22
32.25 / 57.69
56.04 / 83.44
56.43 / 83.36
59.19 / 83.78
52.62 / 78.43
57.87 / 80.90
56.18 / 82.45
60.88 / 84.63
57.03 / 83.37
62.83 / 85.64
zhs → da
91.60 / 84.99
89.12 / 81.43
93.79 / 86.68
94.30 / 87.05
94.69 / 87.76
88.95 / 80.60
91.01 / 82.86
93.30 / 85.80
93.83 / 87.49
94.23 / 86.85
95.46 / 88.70
da → zhs
75.73 / 83.06
45.99 / 54.52
78.97 / 84.62
78.49 / 84.10
81.13 / 84.96
75.43 / 80.93
79.84 / 83.24
77.97 / 83.48
81.72 / 85.70
79.62 / 84.27
83.63 / 86.74
zhs → de
95.06 / 81.56
91.19 / 77.99
95.98 / 83.00
95.97 / 83.11
96.05 / 83.15
92.12 / 75.59
93.72 / 77.56
95.45 / 81.06
96.57 / 82.38
96.10 / 82.89
96.75 / 83.29
de → zhs
79.17 / 81.82
58.12 / 58.51
82.37 / 84.28
82.13 / 83.64
82.90 / 84.99
78.96 / 80.46
82.05 / 84.40
81.41 / 83.08
84.12 / 86.96
82.88 / 84.12
84.90 / 88.15
zhs → el
85.76 / 74.42
83.40 / 71.31
88.12 / 76.97
88.82 / 77.25
88.82 / 77.81
79.06 / 70.31
81.37 / 72.73
87.32 / 76.83
88.31 / 78.33
88.37 / 77.60
89.58 / 79.20
el → zhs
54.66 / 63.81
41.15 / 52.10
59.02 / 66.32
58.01 / 65.43
60.91 / 66.06
56.00 / 61.42
62.05 / 64.67
58.78 / 65.55
64.34 / 67.64
59.90 / 66.49
66.50 / 69.22
zhs → en
97.17 / 87.37
95.65 / 85.36
97.02 / 87.53
97.04 / 87.64
97.14 / 87.75
96.36 / 86.85
96.48 / 87.21
96.97 / 87.61
97.47 / 87.95
97.18 / 87.90
97.61 / 88.27
en → zhs
92.46 / 88.04
74.32 / 62.17
93.33 / 88.78
93.43 / 88.91
93.40 / 88.80
90.42 / 85.65
92.61 / 87.55
93.05 / 88.09
94.99 / 89.67
93.89 / 88.80
95.79 / 90.58
zhs → es
90.02 / 80.34
87.51 / 77.80
91.15 / 81.03
91.55 / 81.25
91.25 / 80.89
89.29 / 78.24
90.96 / 79.14
91.70 / 80.69
92.56 / 80.89
92.00 / 81.26
92.95 / 81.66
es → zhs
81.29 / 77.19
53.43 / 47.01
85.04 / 80.28
85.40 / 79.66
85.98 / 80.98
81.61 / 75.98
85.44 / 81.65
83.87 / 79.51
87.32 / 84.32
85.02 / 80.44
88.46 / 85.16
zhs → fa
86.07 / 79.52
82.13 / 76.25
89.03 / 81.86
88.99 / 82.00
89.02 / 82.51
78.17 / 73.43
82.89 / 77.46
87.22 / 80.76
89.18 / 83.11
88.66 / 81.86
91.37 / 85.01
fa → zhs
71.89 / 73.85
55.41 / 60.70
76.80 / 76.63
76.59 / 76.22
77.87 / 77.22
71.11 / 71.31
75.95 / 74.34
76.36 / 75.17
79.91 / 77.65
77.63 / 77.05
81.76 / 79.17
zhs → fi
84.70 / 88.28
77.46 / 81.62
89.25 / 90.52
89.73 / 90.73
89.97 / 91.13
74.15 / 77.15
78.83 / 80.99
87.12 / 88.11
88.30 / 90.20
88.72 / 90.02
90.98 / 91.90
fi → zhs
52.32 / 83.01
32.23 / 63.73
58.05 / 84.62
58.37 / 84.76
60.52 / 84.73
52.92 / 79.30
58.08 / 80.54
58.01 / 83.80
60.81 / 84.57
57.99 / 84.81
64.79 / 85.97
zhs → fr
80.48 / 81.63
76.83 / 77.16
81.98 / 82.61
82.96 / 82.66
82.35 / 82.25
78.94 / 77.20
80.93 / 79.08
83.04 / 82.05
83.19 / 81.94
83.72 / 82.68
83.82 / 82.49
fr → zhs
62.20 / 72.88
40.52 / 46.44
67.53 / 77.24
66.92 / 75.77
70.02 / 76.72
64.44 / 71.62
71.16 / 78.29
67.30 / 75.61
74.32 / 82.51
68.68 / 76.60
76.01 / 84.48
zhs → he
79.86 / 73.53
78.83 / 71.00
83.63 / 76.94
83.95 / 77.51
84.89 / 77.59
71.88 / 66.49
74.79 / 70.49
83.00 / 75.87
85.22 / 78.47
84.78 / 77.38
87.13 / 79.92
he → zhs
72.41 / 73.67
48.52 / 54.19
75.85 / 75.77
76.04 / 75.84
76.96 / 76.06
71.41 / 70.67
75.36 / 72.69
74.57 / 74.52
78.17 / 75.84
75.54 / 75.44
78.91 / 76.80
Table 12: Reference-based English-centric evaluation results (spBLEU / XCOMET) of baseline models (Part I) on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
TranslateGemma-4B
TranslateGemma-12B
TranslateGemma-27B
GemmaX2-28-2B
GemmaX2-28-9B
Hunyuan-MT-7B
HY-MT1.5-1.8B
HY-MT1.5-7B
HY-MT2-1.8B
HY-MT2-7B
HY-MT2-30B-A3B
Seed-X-Instruct-7B
Seed-X-PPO-7B
Tower-Plus-2B
Tower-Plus-9B
Tower-Plus-72B
en → ar
31.42 / 92.06
33.73 / 94.89
33.79 / 96.20
37.71 / 90.33
41.91 / 93.56
32.27 / 95.46
27.96 / 92.30
32.68 / 95.57
34.00 / 92.05
38.39 / 94.93
38.80 / 95.37
41.78 / 92.87
42.62 / 93.38
- / -
- / -
- / -
ar → en
34.36 / 89.18
36.37 / 92.60
40.06 / 94.09
45.26 / 92.01
48.05 / 94.18
32.52 / 92.22
26.51 / 89.55
33.42 / 92.72
34.33 / 89.79
42.98 / 93.51
44.06 / 94.45
47.05 / 92.38
43.72 / 94.36
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → az
6.82 / 39.69
18.27 / 78.24
21.93 / 86.27
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
az → en
20.84 / 76.12
23.68 / 85.74
26.14 / 88.98
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → bn
24.35 / 87.37
24.81 / 91.23
26.10 / 92.14
31.60 / 88.23
33.13 / 90.80
24.89 / 92.34
22.67 / 88.91
25.77 / 92.72
25.82 / 88.82
28.90 / 92.54
27.63 / 93.28
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bn → en
28.66 / 85.75
31.33 / 89.90
34.53 / 91.73
39.77 / 89.28
42.80 / 91.36
25.16 / 85.21
21.36 / 85.78
28.52 / 86.98
27.55 / 85.04
35.89 / 89.31
37.36 / 91.97
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → bg
37.72 / 92.11
39.33 / 96.08
40.82 / 97.21
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bg → en
37.76 / 92.29
39.51 / 94.25
42.45 / 95.71
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → ca
38.42 / 91.34
42.09 / 95.57
39.11 / 96.30
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
ca → en
42.43 / 92.31
44.23 / 94.61
46.79 / 95.66
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → cs
31.32 / 89.73
34.86 / 94.60
34.17 / 95.36
40.65 / 91.87
43.74 / 94.23
38.43 / 94.77
33.69 / 90.20
38.16 / 94.70
38.83 / 90.52
43.00 / 94.87
42.99 / 95.54
40.76 / 93.64
44.51 / 94.48
39.95 / 91.66
43.28 / 94.33
42.19 / 93.64
cs → en
37.57 / 93.31
38.32 / 95.06
41.36 / 95.92
46.16 / 95.28
47.78 / 96.08
35.53 / 94.64
30.46 / 93.45
37.11 / 94.52
38.77 / 93.47
44.18 / 95.75
44.35 / 96.26
44.89 / 93.35
45.32 / 96.13
44.70 / 94.73
47.56 / 95.90
47.41 / 96.17
en → zhs
31.02 / 91.99
31.96 / 94.45
33.60 / 95.15
37.94 / 92.88
39.85 / 93.72
31.03 / 96.04
30.57 / 93.81
29.94 / 95.58
35.79 / 93.47
36.01 / 95.64
37.68 / 95.71
37.60 / 94.01
34.09 / 95.28
36.39 / 90.84
39.92 / 93.32
42.21 / 94.51
zhs → en
27.24 / 95.63
28.90 / 96.71
30.94 / 97.27
34.68 / 96.48
36.57 / 96.96
29.57 / 96.86
23.89 / 96.00
27.48 / 96.82
26.95 / 96.17
28.98 / 97.04
29.82 / 97.68
36.47 / 96.46
33.19 / 96.86
32.02 / 95.53
34.78 / 96.77
36.72 / 97.26
en → zht
12.41 / 89.41
12.04 / 92.73
27.31 / 94.66
- / -
- / -
8.43 / 94.26
8.44 / 92.63
24.16 / 94.27
10.72 / 91.19
29.46 / 94.64
29.71 / 95.18
- / -
- / -
30.11 / 88.95
33.01 / 92.11
31.59 / 93.14
zht → en
25.80 / 93.78
27.46 / 95.70
29.78 / 96.49
- / -
- / -
27.86 / 95.48
22.01 / 93.96
27.98 / 95.33
27.07 / 93.67
32.18 / 95.77
33.27 / 96.62
- / -
- / -
29.92 / 93.99
33.39 / 96.06
35.84 / 96.62
en → da
42.35 / 95.94
43.94 / 97.72
41.86 / 98.22
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
51.01 / 97.19
54.91 / 97.38
50.91 / 96.01
53.66 / 97.16
51.88 / 96.65
da → en
45.10 / 95.11
46.14 / 96.18
47.73 / 97.13
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
54.25 / 95.61
53.33 / 97.22
53.28 / 96.27
55.60 / 97.26
54.95 / 97.25
en → de
39.21 / 97.73
40.28 / 98.50
41.85 / 98.89
45.58 / 97.66
49.34 / 98.26
40.68 / 98.60
35.01 / 97.66
41.18 / 98.58
40.89 / 97.48
46.03 / 98.42
46.78 / 98.72
49.02 / 98.30
49.72 / 97.95
44.95 / 97.50
48.62 / 98.38
48.11 / 98.43
de → en
41.12 / 95.49
42.10 / 96.49
44.22 / 97.05
49.53 / 96.72
50.85 / 97.12
39.01 / 96.47
33.40 / 95.93
40.03 / 96.30
42.34 / 95.61
47.24 / 97.01
47.59 / 97.39
50.92 / 96.28
49.19 / 97.13
48.38 / 96.22
50.24 / 97.18
51.11 / 97.33
en → el
30.38 / 88.80
34.32 / 93.37
35.38 / 95.49
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
el → en
33.40 / 90.76
35.27 / 93.40
37.86 / 94.73
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → tl
30.08 / 86.91
32.59 / 90.38
35.55 / 90.46
38.05 / 87.46
40.11 / 89.36
26.18 / 84.06
25.67 / 87.60
26.74 / 84.10
32.79 / 87.79
36.27 / 90.84
35.48 / 91.17
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
tl → en
39.74 / 91.04
40.59 / 93.52
45.31 / 94.87
52.76 / 93.48
55.75 / 94.68
35.20 / 92.49
30.05 / 91.40
37.00 / 92.61
40.61 / 90.82
48.18 / 93.76
48.79 / 94.59
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
en → fi
27.19 / 87.98
30.98 / 94.05
32.21 / 95.63
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
43.49 / 93.72
45.60 / 94.74
32.93 / 89.80
37.95 / 94.42
35.31 / 92.43
fi → en
33.37 / 90.81
35.72 / 94.06
37.14 / 95.34
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
41.75 / 93.24
39.90 / 95.10
38.80 / 92.84
42.19 / 95.34
42.34 / 95.55
en → fr
47.04 / 93.78
47.47 / 95.77
44.06 / 96.17
54.59 / 93.97
57.60 / 95.74
44.54 / 95.53
39.72 / 93.16
44.60 / 95.84
47.94 / 93.34
52.04 / 95.77
51.75 / 96.07
57.41 / 95.19
57.91 / 95.15
54.32 / 93.61
56.14 / 95.79
56.85 / 95.74
fr → en
42.48 / 94.60
42.79 / 95.35
45.11 / 96.11
50.27 / 96.18
51.34 / 96.54
38.67 / 95.53
33.00 / 94.62
39.79 / 95.42
43.00 / 95.27
47.24 / 96.28
48.15 / 96.54
49.71 / 93.94
49.71 / 96.62
49.41 / 96.00
50.49 / 96.47
51.76 / 96.52
en → he
29.39 / 84.93
34.42 / 93.30
37.17 / 95.24
42.71 / 89.97
47.20 / 93.46
29.60 / 88.09
25.78 / 84.36
30.48 / 88.73
34.87 / 86.64
42.37 / 93.34
42.47 / 94.57
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
he → en
36.88 / 90.28
40.06 / 93.98
43.73 / 95.79
48.36 / 94.32
50.92 / 95.79
34.08 / 91.60
27.92 / 89.12
35.90 / 92.11
36.36 / 89.04
45.64 / 94.56
46.72 / 95.64
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
Table 13: Reference-based English-centric evaluation results (spBLEU / XCOMET) of baseline models (Part II) and MiLMMT models on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
Google Translate
NLLB-54.5B
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Gemini 3 Pro
GPT-5
MiLMMT-46-1B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-4B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-12B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
en → ar
44.90 / 95.14
43.03 / 90.90
41.55 / 95.43
43.60 / 95.78
38.68 / 94.69
34.99 / 87.04
33.66 / 88.67
40.31 / 93.00
37.48 / 93.95
42.61 / 94.34
38.48 / 95.90
ar → en
50.99 / 94.87
48.26 / 92.50
49.55 / 95.54
49.26 / 95.67
46.74 / 95.10
42.43 / 90.13
41.25 / 90.60
46.94 / 93.51
45.54 / 93.63
48.92 / 94.78
47.23 / 94.96
en → az
26.51 / 82.61
24.63 / 79.16
27.41 / 90.16
28.07 / 90.47
25.85 / 89.46
22.27 / 76.34
21.73 / 79.44
25.64 / 86.38
24.96 / 88.19
26.95 / 88.76
25.89 / 90.61
az → en
33.24 / 90.76
31.94 / 87.01
31.77 / 91.71
32.12 / 91.82
29.73 / 91.43
26.22 / 84.35
25.31 / 86.04
29.18 / 89.82
28.23 / 90.22
30.49 / 90.89
29.24 / 91.71
en → bn
37.55 / 88.41
36.04 / 85.21
33.47 / 90.64
32.86 / 92.28
28.46 / 89.72
27.62 / 83.29
25.69 / 86.41
31.66 / 89.69
28.59 / 92.01
32.73 / 91.35
29.01 / 93.51
bn → en
44.97 / 91.90
42.22 / 89.21
44.35 / 92.95
44.18 / 93.28
41.50 / 93.03
36.85 / 86.34
36.20 / 87.79
41.63 / 90.72
40.39 / 91.37
43.04 / 91.92
41.73 / 92.52
en → bg
53.44 / 95.44
49.98 / 92.10
51.39 / 96.37
52.29 / 96.67
47.61 / 95.70
45.61 / 90.51
43.85 / 91.80
50.79 / 95.03
47.97 / 95.89
51.87 / 95.99
47.29 / 96.79
bg → en
51.32 / 95.77
47.01 / 93.54
49.37 / 95.97
50.52 / 96.21
47.86 / 95.65
45.53 / 93.52
44.19 / 94.01
48.59 / 95.45
47.04 / 95.80
49.75 / 95.87
47.88 / 96.05
en → ca
52.33 / 94.98
48.85 / 92.54
50.96 / 95.73
52.19 / 95.50
46.53 / 95.40
46.20 / 92.63
44.31 / 93.51
49.40 / 94.87
45.58 / 95.51
50.78 / 95.59
47.46 / 96.47
ca → en
55.13 / 95.67
52.58 / 93.77
53.02 / 96.02
54.53 / 96.33
52.30 / 96.08
49.90 / 94.05
48.86 / 94.42
52.34 / 95.61
51.10 / 95.89
53.84 / 96.18
52.40 / 96.27
en → cs
46.66 / 94.30
42.38 / 90.10
44.94 / 95.55
46.44 / 95.62
43.66 / 95.67
37.56 / 87.71
36.82 / 89.82
42.69 / 93.73
40.96 / 94.92
44.91 / 95.14
41.89 / 95.79
cs → en
49.97 / 96.15
45.31 / 94.15
47.78 / 96.35
48.71 / 96.56
46.31 / 96.11
44.22 / 94.02
42.85 / 94.59
46.94 / 95.94
45.17 / 96.22
48.39 / 96.37
46.67 / 96.58
en → zhs
44.05 / 93.84
26.61 / 76.72
39.42 / 94.26
40.26 / 94.43
37.73 / 94.19
35.03 / 90.32
34.22 / 91.77
38.03 / 93.21
36.84 / 94.55
38.98 / 94.11
37.33 / 95.28
zhs → en
39.59 / 97.18
36.13 / 95.04
38.26 / 97.28
38.12 / 97.38
34.82 / 97.52
32.44 / 95.14
30.84 / 95.57
35.40 / 96.59
33.74 / 96.79
36.60 / 97.21
34.94 / 97.38
en → zht
33.84 / 92.75
12.44 / 56.52
33.63 / 93.86
35.49 / 94.20
31.41 / 93.59
27.61 / 88.67
26.77 / 90.43
30.76 / 92.20
28.36 / 93.69
32.45 / 93.48
29.70 / 94.92
zht → en
37.95 / 96.15
32.27 / 92.00
37.02 / 96.88
37.13 / 97.20
33.52 / 96.86
30.77 / 93.61
29.61 / 94.05
33.21 / 95.81
31.98 / 95.87
34.77 / 96.42
33.43 / 96.71
en → da
55.61 / 97.25
50.04 / 95.66
53.61 / 98.02
54.62 / 98.18
51.23 / 97.82
49.11 / 95.10
47.78 / 95.63
52.57 / 97.14
50.55 / 97.60
54.70 / 97.81
51.72 / 98.31
da → en
58.03 / 97.39
53.07 / 95.43
54.84 / 97.40
55.88 / 97.52
53.48 / 97.23
53.32 / 95.92
52.19 / 96.14
55.01 / 97.23
53.94 / 97.43
55.72 / 97.45
54.44 / 97.49
en → de
49.24 / 98.81
46.62 / 97.50
49.54 / 98.55
51.94 / 98.67
47.64 / 98.12
43.10 / 96.45
40.74 / 96.93
47.32 / 98.28
45.88 / 98.45
48.91 / 98.50
46.04 / 98.83
de → en
52.41 / 97.24
49.80 / 96.06
50.31 / 97.16
51.05 / 97.31
49.52 / 97.12
47.82 / 95.87
46.73 / 95.99
49.91 / 96.84
48.51 / 97.05
51.28 / 97.20
49.43 / 97.33
en → el
42.95 / 93.61
38.73 / 91.03
42.78 / 95.01
43.62 / 94.86
41.10 / 94.26
35.76 / 87.18
35.47 / 88.87
40.61 / 93.29
39.40 / 94.34
42.02 / 94.31
41.05 / 95.52
el → en
45.33 / 94.85
43.70 / 93.79
44.00 / 95.12
43.51 / 95.45
41.68 / 95.03
38.94 / 91.92
37.33 / 92.47
42.19 / 94.64
40.84 / 94.97
43.52 / 95.33
42.16 / 95.46
en → tl
39.72 / 82.85
38.34 / 83.28
38.74 / 90.18
40.47 / 90.53
38.45 / 90.12
33.97 / 83.60
32.48 / 86.15
37.96 / 87.95
35.10 / 90.14
39.53 / 89.18
36.66 / 91.77
tl → en
58.10 / 94.74
54.58 / 92.86
56.49 / 95.01
56.90 / 95.08
52.61 / 95.00
49.06 / 91.45
47.64 / 91.94
53.41 / 94.21
51.93 / 94.57
55.41 / 94.92
53.80 / 95.10
en → fi
42.30 / 94.59
36.57 / 90.00
42.85 / 96.63
44.74 / 96.74
40.05 / 95.98
30.78 / 83.81
30.29 / 84.93
37.12 / 93.26
36.22 / 94.29
39.92 / 95.00
39.06 / 95.92
fi → en
44.26 / 95.41
41.22 / 92.87
42.56 / 95.72
43.23 / 96.07
41.05 / 95.78
37.82 / 92.00
37.09 / 92.64
41.12 / 95.09
40.01 / 95.13
42.35 / 95.80
40.91 / 95.80
en → fr
59.40 / 95.81
56.16 / 92.44
56.82 / 95.68
59.16 / 96.06
53.18 / 95.76
51.67 / 92.44
48.76 / 93.11
55.45 / 95.21
50.97 / 95.51
57.64 / 95.74
51.68 / 96.42
fr → en
54.39 / 96.33
51.54 / 95.11
51.46 / 96.39
52.26 / 96.77
49.82 / 96.45
48.37 / 95.58
47.24 / 95.80
50.40 / 96.60
48.67 / 96.58
51.60 / 96.71
50.23 / 96.90
en → he
51.65 / 93.63
46.82 / 90.79
48.01 / 94.89
51.50 / 95.15
45.42 / 94.02
37.22 / 83.68
35.53 / 84.96
45.45 / 92.33
41.66 / 93.60
48.52 / 94.52
43.61 / 95.36
he → en
53.64 / 95.84
49.02 / 92.85
52.37 / 96.63
52.61 / 96.92
49.84 / 96.10
45.33 / 91.03
43.95 / 91.47
49.92 / 95.20
48.54 / 95.18
51.57 / 96.09
49.95 / 96.11
Table 14: Reference-based Chinese-centric evaluation results (spBLEU / XCOMET) of baseline models (Part I) on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
TranslateGemma-4B
TranslateGemma-12B
TranslateGemma-27B
GemmaX2-28-2B
GemmaX2-28-9B
Hunyuan-MT-7B
HY-MT1.5-1.8B
HY-MT1.5-7B
HY-MT2-1.8B
HY-MT2-7B
HY-MT2-30B-A3B
Seed-X-Instruct-7B
Seed-X-PPO-7B
Tower-Plus-2B
Tower-Plus-9B
Tower-Plus-72B
zhs → ar
20.57 / 85.48
22.40 / 90.53
23.94 / 92.21
23.78 / 85.41
28.27 / 90.53
23.10 / 91.34
20.05 / 86.54
22.37 / 91.54
22.22 / 87.65
24.07 / 92.15
26.50 / 92.09
26.36 / 88.77
26.77 / 90.74
- / -
- / -
- / -
ar → zhs
23.42 / 81.50
26.12 / 87.23
28.87 / 88.59
29.88 / 83.94
32.97 / 87.55
22.93 / 88.19
22.40 / 84.78
24.11 / 88.83
23.76 / 84.67
24.10 / 89.41
30.56 / 90.10
31.85 / 86.49
27.59 / 87.27
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → az
4.75 / 34.69
15.04 / 71.10
17.28 / 79.83
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
az → zhs
18.51 / 68.43
21.47 / 78.90
23.13 / 81.09
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → bn
16.84 / 83.05
18.08 / 88.10
20.66 / 89.69
20.33 / 84.02
23.41 / 88.28
18.16 / 87.60
16.49 / 83.25
17.86 / 88.29
17.70 / 84.48
18.86 / 90.62
20.53 / 91.40
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bn → zhs
21.35 / 74.92
24.93 / 81.79
26.90 / 83.97
26.94 / 78.04
30.01 / 82.77
18.29 / 77.93
18.56 / 76.90
20.32 / 80.24
19.01 / 76.65
20.88 / 83.59
27.33 / 85.93
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → bg
23.72 / 87.94
25.90 / 93.10
28.28 / 94.30
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
bg → zhs
26.16 / 84.38
28.24 / 87.89
30.11 / 88.89
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → ca
21.71 / 84.58
25.94 / 90.70
24.19 / 92.08
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
ca → zhs
26.10 / 81.89
28.91 / 87.52
30.81 / 88.52
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → cs
19.44 / 79.11
22.18 / 87.18
23.52 / 88.99
25.40 / 84.69
28.55 / 89.72
23.53 / 88.14
20.62 / 80.47
22.57 / 88.11
24.81 / 83.93
28.24 / 89.99
28.96 / 91.21
26.13 / 85.35
28.68 / 89.67
23.50 / 82.00
27.47 / 88.88
28.39 / 89.56
cs → zhs
25.91 / 80.51
27.66 / 84.90
29.77 / 86.22
31.14 / 82.51
34.05 / 85.17
24.99 / 87.15
24.04 / 84.15
25.20 / 87.15
26.91 / 83.76
26.93 / 88.42
33.24 / 87.18
32.84 / 82.62
30.17 / 84.50
29.81 / 78.89
33.81 / 83.99
36.21 / 84.79
zhs → zht
11.59 / 94.06
19.39 / 95.16
29.06 / 96.05
- / -
- / -
25.22 / 95.35
23.86 / 94.62
25.86 / 95.60
28.17 / 95.29
26.96 / 96.15
29.47 / 94.65
- / -
- / -
30.81 / 94.26
26.00 / 94.27
29.78 / 94.57
zht → zhs
10.84 / 94.19
31.17 / 95.18
32.75 / 95.39
- / -
- / -
28.87 / 95.83
28.03 / 94.65
28.33 / 95.71
30.76 / 93.62
31.03 / 94.45
29.55 / 92.43
- / -
- / -
33.23 / 93.65
34.43 / 94.28
34.35 / 94.01
zhs → da
22.74 / 91.40
25.52 / 94.77
26.23 / 95.83
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
29.00 / 93.91
30.91 / 95.58
25.54 / 91.99
28.98 / 94.68
29.85 / 95.07
da → zhs
26.93 / 87.00
29.11 / 90.98
30.93 / 91.69
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
33.99 / 89.84
31.16 / 91.23
30.70 / 86.48
34.94 / 89.98
37.03 / 90.85
zhs → de
22.32 / 95.26
24.66 / 97.34
26.45 / 97.78
28.04 / 96.11
30.67 / 97.39
25.36 / 97.37
20.03 / 94.66
24.76 / 97.36
23.12 / 95.98
25.67 / 97.48
28.37 / 98.05
29.03 / 97.08
30.82 / 97.61
24.82 / 95.31
29.04 / 97.23
30.08 / 97.46
de → zhs
26.79 / 87.69
28.18 / 91.89
29.80 / 92.57
32.39 / 89.90
34.64 / 91.81
26.32 / 93.15
25.73 / 91.29
25.85 / 93.26
28.85 / 90.84
28.55 / 93.43
31.23 / 93.94
33.54 / 91.04
29.53 / 92.03
30.39 / 87.43
34.49 / 91.10
36.15 / 92.05
zhs → el
20.10 / 81.89
24.24 / 89.95
26.17 / 91.70
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
el → zhs
22.79 / 79.35
25.82 / 84.52
27.94 / 85.51
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → en
27.24 / 95.63
28.90 / 96.71
30.94 / 97.27
34.68 / 96.48
36.57 / 96.96
29.57 / 96.86
23.89 / 96.00
27.48 / 96.82
26.95 / 96.17
28.98 / 97.04
29.82 / 97.68
36.47 / 96.46
33.19 / 96.86
32.02 / 95.53
34.78 / 96.77
36.72 / 97.26
en → zhs
31.02 / 91.99
31.96 / 94.45
33.60 / 95.15
37.94 / 92.88
39.85 / 93.72
31.03 / 96.04
30.57 / 93.81
29.94 / 95.58
35.79 / 93.47
36.01 / 95.64
37.68 / 95.71
37.60 / 94.01
34.09 / 95.28
36.39 / 90.84
39.92 / 93.32
42.21 / 94.51
zhs → tl
18.44 / 82.16
20.95 / 86.47
23.21 / 87.89
23.44 / 83.91
25.74 / 86.88
17.81 / 79.00
16.72 / 80.67
17.21 / 79.27
20.90 / 83.77
24.23 / 88.14
25.07 / 88.47
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
tl → zhs
25.73 / 74.28
27.41 / 80.25
29.86 / 81.63
31.42 / 77.91
34.20 / 80.73
23.22 / 80.73
23.17 / 77.04
23.82 / 80.99
26.39 / 77.64
25.74 / 83.34
32.49 / 83.16
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
zhs → fi
17.40 / 77.32
21.62 / 87.49
23.32 / 90.29
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
27.87 / 85.96
29.19 / 90.04
20.57 / 81.75
25.33 / 89.53
24.80 / 88.02
fi → zhs
24.45 / 80.16
26.60 / 86.33
28.57 / 87.24
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
31.45 / 82.90
28.18 / 84.84
27.73 / 79.77
32.30 / 80.85
33.81 / 85.54
zhs → fr
27.86 / 84.17
30.30 / 88.21
29.75 / 89.78
33.99 / 87.57
36.76 / 90.82
29.40 / 89.32
24.35 / 85.62
28.54 / 89.34
29.19 / 86.69
32.01 / 90.36
33.69 / 91.65
36.43 / 89.25
35.23 / 91.02
30.17 / 84.99
33.70 / 89.90
35.61 / 91.42
fr → zhs
26.80 / 85.25
28.26 / 88.69
29.81 / 89.42
32.53 / 86.39
34.74 / 87.88
26.36 / 90.78
25.47 / 87.64
25.98 / 90.87
29.10 / 87.28
28.36 / 91.08
32.62 / 90.50
33.71 / 86.59
30.29 / 88.72
30.27 / 83.46
34.26 / 87.35
36.22 / 88.39
zhs → he
17.50 / 78.51
22.43 / 89.71
25.07 / 91.72
25.00 / 84.69
28.36 / 90.70
18.51 / 81.85
8.12 / 74.47
19.08 / 83.97
19.57 / 82.23
22.87 / 91.40
25.92 / 92.13
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
he → zhs
24.27 / 82.54
27.10 / 88.67
30.14 / 90.15
30.68 / 86.11
33.60 / 89.02
22.40 / 87.55
21.81 / 83.82
23.40 / 88.08
23.75 / 83.98
24.23 / 90.43
29.09 / 91.74
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
- / -
Table 15: Reference-based Chinese-centric evaluation results (spBLEU / XCOMET) of baseline models (Part II) and MiLMMT models on the FLORES+ benchmark.
Direction
Google Translate
NLLB-54.5B
Gemini 2.5 Pro
Gemini 3 Pro
GPT-5
MiLMMT-46-1B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-4B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-4B-v1.0
MiLMMT-46-12B-v0.1
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0
zhs → ar
31.72 / 91.10
27.53 / 86.46
29.47 / 92.89
30.70 / 93.03
26.38 / 92.23
21.96 / 81.00
21.59 / 82.73
26.33 / 88.56
25.33 / 89.73
28.77 / 91.25
27.13 / 92.36
ar → zhs
37.23 / 87.26
21.25 / 70.04
34.46 / 89.09
35.09 / 89.37
32.71 / 89.05
26.16 / 80.95
26.13 / 82.10
30.85 / 85.73
30.42 / 87.01
32.55 / 88.06
32.00 / 89.16
zhs → az
21.35 / 79.59
19.24 / 70.95
22.51 / 86.13
22.90 / 86.77
20.43 / 84.90
16.86 / 66.61
16.48 / 69.88
19.86 / 79.83
18.91 / 81.08
21.21 / 84.04
20.46 / 84.95
az → zhs
30.41 / 79.10
19.32 / 64.19
27.77 / 82.79
28.12 / 82.86
25.42 / 83.07
21.06 / 70.93
20.83 / 73.74
25.17 / 79.29
24.55 / 80.79
26.56 / 81.08
25.76 / 82.83
zhs → bn
28.29 / 86.23
23.67 / 81.38
24.99 / 89.62
25.28 / 90.72
21.08 / 90.00
17.26 / 78.55
17.51 / 81.08
21.89 / 87.10
20.13 / 88.57
23.36 / 89.17
21.52 / 90.90
bn → zhs
34.34 / 82.48
20.01 / 63.34
31.52 / 85.02
32.57 / 85.09
30.31 / 85.45
23.20 / 72.94
23.47 / 75.43
28.46 / 80.47
27.97 / 82.44
30.24 / 83.32
29.62 / 85.00
zhs → bg
36.71 / 94.01
30.60 / 87.40
34.66 / 95.22
35.53 / 95.40
30.27 / 95.01
26.84 / 85.76
26.25 / 87.18
31.48 / 92.71
30.43 / 93.36
33.28 / 94.13
31.90 / 94.58
bg → zhs
37.56 / 86.59
20.07 / 62.52
34.37 / 88.34
35.17 / 88.18
32.55 / 87.96
28.37 / 81.95
28.18 / 83.75
32.38 / 86.17
31.79 / 87.91
33.90 / 87.30
33.13 / 89.11
zhs → ca
34.51 / 91.79
29.58 / 85.53
32.56 / 93.53
34.25 / 93.74
27.94 / 93.75
25.93 / 85.76
25.54 / 87.25
29.86 / 91.47
27.04 / 92.20
32.45 / 92.83
29.26 / 93.63
ca → zhs
38.27 / 85.84
23.32 / 67.61
34.95 / 88.07
35.72 / 87.80
33.38 / 88.15
29.71 / 81.70
29.46 / 83.30
33.30 / 86.21
33.11 / 87.89
34.29 / 87.57
33.77 / 89.37
zhs → cs
32.24 / 90.16
25.63 / 78.74
30.03 / 91.94
31.73 / 92.55
27.70 / 91.77
22.11 / 76.85
21.76 / 80.01
26.64 / 88.21
26.04 / 89.28
29.02 / 90.99
27.70 / 91.09
cs → zhs
37.49 / 83.38
19.60 / 57.22
34.24 / 85.74
34.53 / 85.46
32.31 / 86.04
28.46 / 78.64
28.46 / 80.74
32.24 / 83.61
32.10 / 85.52
33.89 / 85.03
33.21 / 87.11
zhs → zht
30.38 / 94.37
13.14 / 67.33
29.47 / 94.46
29.32 / 94.48
29.23 / 94.43
29.66 / 93.97
28.95 / 94.22
30.71 / 94.92
29.72 / 95.00
30.92 / 95.17
29.65 / 95.72
zht → zhs
28.49 / 91.58
24.10 / 82.35
29.61 / 91.96
29.96 / 92.11
29.56 / 92.15
31.77 / 92.93
32.15 / 93.39
33.74 / 93.91
33.84 / 94.66
34.44 / 94.20
29.34 / 94.67
zhs → da
34.41 / 95.48
28.32 / 90.49
32.07 / 96.75
33.17 / 97.09
29.61 / 97.00
24.93 / 89.35
24.37 / 90.58
29.37 / 94.76
28.43 / 95.27
31.85 / 96.17
30.41 / 96.39
da → zhs
38.86 / 90.50
19.51 / 62.21
35.39 / 91.64
35.93 / 91.39
33.70 / 91.39
30.25 / 86.40
29.91 / 87.30
34.18 / 89.96
33.94 / 91.35
34.76 / 90.93
34.00 / 92.20
zhs → de
33.71 / 97.85
27.15 / 93.92
31.92 / 98.08
32.77 / 98.04
29.21 / 97.89
23.95 / 93.60
23.30 / 94.71
28.45 / 96.90
27.55 / 97.29
30.64 / 97.68
29.22 / 97.92
de → zhs
37.98 / 91.31
21.48 / 71.34
34.80 / 92.50
34.91 / 92.33
32.66 / 92.20
29.24 / 87.59
29.04 / 89.08
32.77 / 90.75
31.89 / 92.09
34.04 / 92.23
33.15 / 93.00
zhs → el
31.35 / 91.24
26.00 / 84.84
31.29 / 92.90
31.95 / 93.14
28.72 / 92.75
22.27 / 79.61
22.55 / 81.50
27.07 / 89.97
26.35 / 90.52
29.29 / 92.08
28.39 / 92.55
el → zhs
35.41 / 82.39
20.76 / 64.25
32.70 / 84.88
33.23 / 84.44
30.77 / 84.92
26.16 / 76.52
25.63 / 78.50
29.71 / 82.27
29.18 / 84.70
32.05 / 84.16
31.11 / 86.04
zhs → en
39.59 / 97.18
36.13 / 95.04
38.26 / 97.28
38.12 / 97.38
34.82 / 97.52
32.44 / 95.14
30.86 / 95.53
35.40 / 96.59
33.76 / 96.79
36.60 / 97.21
34.99 / 97.36
en → zhs
44.05 / 93.84
26.61 / 76.72
39.42 / 94.26
40.26 / 94.43
37.73 / 94.19
35.03 / 90.32
34.23 / 91.75
38.03 / 93.21
36.85 / 94.54
38.98 / 94.11
37.30 / 95.32
zhs → tl
25.62 / 82.81
22.81 / 79.27
26.11 / 88.76
26.56 / 89.09
24.28 / 87.82
20.15 / 77.37
19.36 / 80.15
23.92 / 85.37
22.67 / 87.16
25.21 / 87.31
23.94 / 89.04
tl → zhs
38.06 / 79.55
21.61 / 61.36
34.81 / 81.94
35.80 / 81.73
32.34 / 81.99
27.68 / 73.83
27.17 / 75.28
32.15 / 79.13
31.34 / 81.46
33.62 / 80.86
32.45 / 82.63
zhs → fi
30.34 / 90.74
23.09 / 80.21
30.38 / 93.70
31.99 / 94.01
27.79 / 93.17
18.22 / 72.38
18.02 / 75.88
24.37 / 88.05
23.56 / 88.99
27.70 / 91.28
26.69 / 92.25
fi → zhs
35.43 / 84.37
18.72 / 57.59
33.03 / 86.40
33.75 / 86.81
31.33 / 86.97
26.03 / 78.18
26.02 / 79.88
31.06 / 84.61
30.38 / 85.84
32.53 / 86.08
31.46 / 87.96
zhs → fr
39.17 / 91.05
34.16 / 83.32
37.57 / 91.97
38.91 / 92.35
33.42 / 91.48
30.47 / 83.15
28.47 / 84.27
34.99 / 89.39
31.82 / 90.01
36.63 / 90.98
33.62 / 91.75
fr → zhs
38.27 / 86.91
21.19 / 63.19
34.52 / 89.06
34.94 / 88.71
32.83 / 88.93
29.68 / 83.12
29.66 / 85.07
32.67 / 87.05
31.94 / 88.43
34.00 / 88.04
33.47 / 90.30
zhs → he
34.40 / 90.22
27.04 / 84.83
30.38 / 92.79
32.47 / 92.88
27.35 / 92.58
18.70 / 75.10
19.36 / 77.41
26.33 / 88.70
25.01 / 89.71
29.13 / 91.37
27.85 / 92.54
he → zhs
38.02 / 88.74
19.77 / 65.10
35.10 / 90.40
35.51 / 90.49
33.13 / 89.97
26.47 / 80.89
26.31 / 82.34
31.83 / 87.45
31.59 / 88.62
33.39 / 89.13
32.72 / 90.40
Table 16: Full on-policy distillation results as 46-language. All students are distilled from the fixed MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0 teacher. WMT24++ cells report reference-free XCOMET / COMETKiwi; each FLORES+ cell reports spBLEU / reference-based XCOMET / reference-free XCOMET / COMETKiwi.
Model
WMT24++
FLORES+
en → xx
en → xx
xx → en
zh → xx
xx → zh
1B students
RL+OPD λ=1
78.25/75.35
33.87/87.79/90.71/86.56
39.65/91.17/90.65/88.27
21.64/82.24/82.76/77.77
26.77/81.48/67.18/76.93
RL+OPD λ=0.5
78.58/75.69
33.76/87.90/90.90/86.72
39.41/91.24/90.75/88.30
21.63/82.43/82.97/78.00
26.70/81.57/67.50/77.10
RL+OPD λ=0.1
79.37/76.41
33.32/88.38/91.39/87.19
38.56/91.44/91.02/88.36
21.34/82.93/83.66/78.61
26.40/81.89/68.14/77.43
RL+OPD λ=0.05
79.83/76.68
32.66/88.49/91.56/87.29
38.02/91.47/91.11/88.37
21.04/83.00/83.72/78.80
26.04/82.09/68.39/77.84
RL+OPD λ=0.01
80.29/77.01
31.11/88.53/91.74/87.29
37.33/91.45/91.14/88.33
20.47/83.12/83.95/78.97
24.89/82.10/68.74/77.78
RL+OPD λ=0.001
80.42/77.08
29.65/88.37/91.66/87.29
36.30/91.46/91.15/88.24
19.70/82.82/83.82/79.14
24.12/82.05/68.51/77.79
RL+OPD λ=10−4
80.26/76.92
30.03/88.32/91.62/87.19
36.65/91.45/91.11/88.27
19.89/82.82/83.93/79.08
24.18/82.04/69.08/77.97
OPD (PG)
77.67/74.66
33.95/87.19/90.21/86.03
39.78/90.97/90.42/88.19
21.44/81.63/82.13/77.17
26.70/81.07/66.70/76.58
OPD (GKD)
77.42/74.37
32.90/87.12/90.11/85.91
39.54/90.96/90.44/88.15
20.83/81.32/81.77/76.86
26.35/81.02/66.56/76.40
OPD (PG, init. v1.0)
77.86/74.93
33.87/87.45/90.43/86.29
39.58/91.06/90.54/88.23
21.43/81.93/82.40/77.42
26.69/81.23/66.87/76.68
4B students
RL+OPD λ=1
85.85/82.23
37.09/93.34/95.15/91.12
42.70/93.98/92.78/89.41
25.44/89.92/88.56/82.36
30.68/86.67/70.43/79.99
RL+OPD λ=0.5
86.03/82.45
36.81/93.44/95.27/91.27
42.43/94.03/92.86/89.42
25.22/89.96/88.60/82.51
30.43/86.89/70.59/80.17
RL+OPD λ=0.1
86.67/82.95
35.40/93.72/95.57/91.57
41.59/94.11/93.00/89.42
24.55/90.13/88.93/82.85
29.67/87.27/71.50/80.57
RL+OPD λ=0.05
87.03/83.17
34.25/93.74/95.62/91.66
41.22/94.10/93.03/89.41
24.01/90.09/88.97/82.95
29.18/87.30/71.36/80.55
RL+OPD λ=0.01
87.62/83.46
31.76/93.89/95.88/91.77
41.06/94.16/92.99/89.39
23.38/90.19/88.96/83.28
28.19/87.61/71.41/80.66
RL+OPD λ=0.001
87.68/83.57
30.35/93.87/95.88/91.80
40.64/94.13/92.95/89.38
22.70/90.16/89.03/83.45
27.12/87.71/71.98/80.94
RL+OPD λ=10−4
87.74/83.45
30.41/93.85/95.83/91.74
40.27/94.14/92.99/89.36
22.63/90.06/89.01/83.52
26.63/87.63/71.56/80.67
OPD (PG)
85.42/81.86
37.56/93.15/94.97/90.94
42.88/93.91/92.68/89.37
25.46/89.74/88.36/82.13
30.80/86.47/70.01/79.79
OPD (GKD)
85.62/81.96
36.97/93.21/95.01/91.01
42.68/93.94/92.76/89.38
25.28/89.76/88.36/82.25
30.71/86.58/70.08/79.88
OPD (PG, init. v1.0)
85.37/81.85
37.53/93.14/94.97/90.97
42.78/93.89/92.71/89.40
25.47/89.69/88.32/82.09
30.85/86.45/70.08/79.76
Findings
Averaged across the three model scales, reference-free XCOMET and COMETKiwi on WMT24++ improved by 2.75 and 2.44 points respectively over the SFT baseline.
On FLORES+, reference-based XCOMET improved by 1.17 points, reference-free XCOMET by 1.41 points, and COMETKiwi by 1.17 points, while spBLEU decreased by 1.21 points, relative to the SFT baseline.
MiLMMT-46-12B-v1.0 achieved the highest reference-free XCOMET and COMETKiwi scores on WMT24++ and across all four FLORES+ direction groups, outperforming evaluated proprietary systems including Google Translate, Gemini 2.5/3 Pro, and GPT-5.
MiLMMT-46-1B-v1.0 outperformed TranslateGemma-4B on every reported WMT24++ and FLORES+ metric despite using only a quarter of the parameters.
On-policy distillation (RL+OPD, lambda=1) into 1B and 4B students approached but did not consistently match the corresponding MiLMMT-46-v1.0 baselines (e.g., 4B model: 34.17 vs. 33.96 spBLEU, 90.82 vs. 90.91 reference-based XCOMET on FLORES+).
Where it can be used
Post-training translation models for low-resource language pairs using only source-side text, when reference translations are hard to obtain.
Designing language-identification-gated reward functions in RL to reduce fluent-but-wrong-language outputs in generative translation systems.
Using on-policy distillation as an alternative to running full reinforcement learning separately at every model scale when transferring quality gains to smaller models.
Applying SFT-RL checkpoint interpolation to control the trade-off between lexical overlap (spBLEU) and learned quality-estimation scores in deployed systems.
Limits and open work
Evaluation is limited to 46 languages, the WMT24++ and FLORES+ benchmarks, and the specific baseline models compared, so performance on other languages or domains is unverified.
RL tends to lower spBLEU (word-overlap score), and checkpoint interpolation only partially recovers this rather than eliminating the trade-off.
On-policy distillation approaches but does not surpass the quality frontier set by the 12B RL-plus-interpolation teacher, and the reasons for this gap are not further analyzed.
The authors plan future work on more robust, human-aligned reward models, extending reference-free post-training to multimodal multilingual translation, and testing at larger model scales.
The reference-free quality estimators (XCOMET, COMETKiwi) used for both reward and evaluation may carry their own biases, which were not independently validated in this study.
Why it matters
This shows translation quality can be improved for low-resource languages using only abundant source-side text, reducing the dependency on scarce reference-translation data. The released open models and code let other researchers and developers apply the same reference-free post-training recipe to their own languages or domains.
Terms in this paper
GRPO (Group Relative Policy Optimization) · A reinforcement learning method that generates several candidate translations and learns from the relative differences in their scores
reference-free quality estimation (QE) · Automatic scoring models like XCOMET and COMETKiwi that judge translation quality from source and output text alone, without a correct reference
checkpoint interpolation · Combining two saved model weight snapshots by linearly mixing them in a given ratio to form a new model
on-policy distillation (OPD) · A method where a larger teacher model scores the smaller student's own generated outputs to train the student
spBLEU · A traditional translation metric measuring word/phrase overlap with a correct reference translation
Original abstract (English)
We study reference-free post-training for multilingual machine translation with open large language models. Starting from the supervised-finetuned MiLMMT-46-v0.1 models, we apply Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) with a reward that averages two reference-free quality estimation models and is gated by language identification. We then linearly interpolate the supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and reinforcement learning (RL) model checkpoints to obtain MiLMMT-46-v1.0. Across 46 languages, the resulting models consistently improve translation quality over their SFT counterparts, outperform strong recent open baselines, including Seed-X, HY-MT2, and TranslateGemma, and achieve leading reference-free scores against evaluated proprietary systems such as Google Translate, Gemini 3 Pro, and GPT-5. We further investigate on-policy distillation and find that it reaches, but does not surpass, the quality frontier achieved by RL with checkpoint interpolation. We release the models and code to facilitate future research.
Authors · Chris Han, Pengzhi Gao, Pei Fu, Jian Luan